-----------------------
The author appears to be trying to be conciliatory. He seems to want cessationists and charismatics to get along. This is the appearance, at least.
He attempts to define the issues (at least how he sees them) but has he ever talked to one of his theological adversaries or read anything one of them might have written? It doesn't seem so. We say this because he doesn't accurately present his opponent's positions.
The author asks why charismatics oppose cessationism. Why do charismatics not believe what the author believes? This sort of question indicates ignorance. Of course charismatics believe something different. That is a tautology.
So if the author wants to know what a charismatic really believes, he only needs to have a conversation with one.
Further, he uses terminology that presumes his premise. Additional revelation. Apostolic signs. Modern-day apostolic revelation. Sign-gifts. Sufficiency of Scripture. None of these phrases are found in the Bible. All of them are derived from cessationist understanding, and the use of them makes a charismatic roll his eyes.
We have discussed many of these deceptive and unbiblical terms elsewhere in our blog. Here is a gateway to many of these explanations. Our 18 part series on cessationism begins here.
And we note that he lays the problem at the feet of charismatics. It is they who misunderstand, it is they who lack information, and ultimately it is they who are the heretics. In fact, he has only one piece of advice, and of course it's directed at charismatics. He writes,
"On the (alleged) continuationist side, it would clarify matters if proponents used terms like 'led,' 'showed,' 'taught,' 'spoke' with the clarifying phrase 'through His Word.'"
The arrogance of this is clearly evident. He wants charismatics to "clarify" their language by forfeiting their actual beliefs. Charismatics believe that the Holy Spirit speaks in ways other than "through His Word," so to make such a demand is egregious and condescending.
So if the author wants cessationists and charismatics to stop talking past each other, then he should stop talking past charismatics.
Lastly, this article is completely absent Scripture.
-------------------


