Disclaimer: Some postings contain other author's material. All such material is used here for fair use and discussion purposes.

Tuesday, June 19, 2012

Raising revenue vs. cutting spending - FB conversation

R.W., a FB friend, posted this:


B.R.: Haha! That's pretty funny. If only it was that simple.

R.W.: It is.

B.R.: mmm...no. C'mon man. The rise in our national deficit is not basic math.

Me: spending - revenue = deficit. Lowered spending - revenue = lower deficit.

B.R.: Rich, and how do we raise the revenue with a party line filibuster every time our president wants to get something done?

Me: B.R., my equation was lowered spending. Raising revenue has never balanced the government's budget.

Monday, June 18, 2012

The Best Thing You Can Be is CEO - The Nation

The Nation is hawking merchandise in a fundraising effort. In its latest email to me, The Nation provides this commentary as an inducement to purchase mugs and t-shirts:




"Republicans are slashing state budgets, job growth is sluggish and students are graduating with ever increasing piles of debt. Not everyone is hurting, though. Corporate profits keep climbing and executive pay shows no signs of slowing down. With our mug featuring Calvin Trillin's poem "The Best Thing You Can Be is CEO," perk yourself up with a reminder that some folks always do well—no matter how many economies they crash. Available at Nation Mart, a large portion of the proceeds benefit The Nation."

I'm actually very glad that "Republicans are slashing state budgets," if indeed this is happening. But I doubt it. I challenge the Nation to produce a list of State budgets that are lower this year than last. The amount of decrease has to be substantial (to qualify for the term "slashing"), and there must be at least two states that have done so, since "budgets" is in the plural.

I'm also glad that corporate profits are climbing, because if they're doing well, then they are hiring and making products I want to buy. But again, I question this. Not because there aren't corporations doing well, but because of the generic use of the term "corporation." It suggests a behemoth organization running roughshod over innocents in the pursuit of profit, which certainly qualifies as a stereotype. 



I own a corporation, and it consists of me and my partner. The Obama economy has cost me a great deal over the last 3 years, and I am just now getting back to where I was before the Democrats took over Congress. Oh, and this statistic: 23% of business owners have gone a year without paying themselves. Obviously, "corporations" is an overly broad characterization of a far more diverse situation.

This never-ending fascination with CEO pay amazes me, as if the amount a CEO is paid has anything at all to do with my life circumstances. But I will grant the point about the burden of CEO pay on the corporation, if the Left provides a similar concession about the burden of Big Government on the economy.

Last point. The best thing I can be is not a CEO. If their measure of "best" is a humongous paycheck, then there is something seriously wrong with their thinking. There is so much satisfaction and beauty out there. So many ways to make a living. Family, friends. How crude to reduce the best things in life to what a CEO earns. Truly sad.

Friday, June 15, 2012

Jesus and government - FB conversation


FB friend B.C. posted this: So this explains why our nation is so messed up in so many ways, all of us have something to change.




S.C.: Oh that Jesus he just has to ruin everything!! Feed the hungry,care for the sick and poor. That aint gonna fly!! 


B.C.: The sad truth is this, government continues to expand thereby reducing the effectiveness of the church, yes the church and most Christians feed the hungry, care for the sick, visit those in prison etc., the difference is the church requires accountability and government not so much.


S.C.: Why should anything the government does or does not do have any affect on churches?? Religion is not government. I have read the Ryan budget(God help me it was sooo hard to get through) gonna be alot more people seeking help!

Me: Government cannot be compassionate. It is not a person with feelings. Government inserts itself into our compassion opportunities, taking our resources in the form of taxes. It prevents us from being compassionate.

S.C.: I am not prevented from being compassionate by anyone or anything. I choose to help others and to fight for what I believe in. I stand up and use the brain and heart that I have to try and make this a better world. I choose to be compassionate I do not seek permission.

B.C.: Rich I agree with you, the difference is that most liberals don't understand how much more and better this world would be with less government.

Me: Missing the point. If part of compassion means giving of one's personal wealth, government has a prior claim on your wealth to spend as it sees fit. You don't get to choose your recipient. Used to be, choice was a good thing amongst the left...

Monday, June 11, 2012

Cell phones and driving

This flyer was sent to me by one of the insurance carries I represent. So even insurance companies are perpetuating the fiction that cell phones are a major cause of accidents.  

"Distracted driving" is not synonymous with "cell phone usage while driving." Accidents attributable to cell phone usage while driving is a subset of distracted driving. 

I did an editorial on this subject here.

Friday, June 8, 2012

The right to abortion - a Letters to the editor dialogue - Susan Guinn

I rarely comment on letters to the editor unless I have instigated the dialogue or am mentioned. I am making an exception here. The newest letters, along with my analysis, are last.
--------------------

First letter:

Women are fighters. We began the fight for the right to vote in 1848 at Seneca Falls at the first women’s rights convention.

We won in 1920 with a federal law giving women the right to vote. We began a fight for equal rights in 1923, trying to pass the Equal Rights Amendment giving women the equality they deserve. And we are still fighting for that today. It is outrageous that women still do not make an equal paycheck for equal work. And now we are revisiting the entire Roe v. Wade debate, even though it was decided almost 40 years ago that women deserve the right to privacy and to make that very private decision without the interference from the government.

Frankly, I can’t believe we are still fighting the battles that our mothers and their mothers fought more than 40 years ago. I am outraged that we are facing this struggle in the 21st century. Have we not learned from anything from our tumultuous history? Our nation has dominated, oppressed, subjugated, and overpowered all those that were not in the majority; in other words, everyone who wasn’t white and male. I cannot sit by while the pattern appears to be repeating. We fought this before, and we’ll do it again.

Bridgette Case Guild
-------------
First reply:

This is in reply to Bridgette Case Guild’s letter in the Chronicle some time ago.

She is complaining that Roe v. Wade is still being challenged after some 40 years. Whereas the women’s right to vote was settled in 1920 and is not being challenged anymore.

I will try to explain the difference to you. The fact that women were not allowed to vote before the 1920s did not result in people’s lives being lost. You also state the fact of equal pay for women. I have no problem with either of these. I agree with you. But Roe v. Wade is completely different. Here we are talking about human life being destroyed. In fact, a million a year in the U.S.

It seems that you Pro Choice people only talk about the mothers’ rights. Do you not realize that there is another human life involved? You people never seem to realize this.

This is the reason that Roe v. Wade is constantly being challenged, and it should be until it is overturned. It’s one of the greatest curses of our country.

Bernard Cole
------------
Second reply:

In response to Mr. Cole’s letter on June 4, why is it that men think they have the right to tell a woman what to do with her own body? And don’t forget that it takes the pregnant woman to give that fetus life, if she so chooses to do. We as women don’t go around telling men that they need to go have a vasectomy because you make ugly children or any such thing. Women have all theses rights except the right to do with our body as we please. And keep your religious views and morals to yourself. It’s my uterus and my life! Stay out of it!

Susan Guinn
----------

My analysis:

Ms. Guinn's letter captured my attention for its total absence of logical thought. Her letter is a play-by-play textbook example of stringing a few bumper sticker slogans together. She makes absolutely no attempt to engage the issues or make a refutation of a single point raised by Mr. Cole, instead choosing to spout rhetoric.

1) "...men think they have the right to tell a woman what to do with her own body..." Unfortunately for Ms. Guinn, it is government that tells all of us what we can do with our own bodies. From motorcycle helmets, to soft drink sizes, or nudity, government regularly exercises power over your body.

It isn't MEN who want to control you, Ms. Guinn, it is government. I wonder,are you consistent in your objections to these other controls on your body?

2) "... it takes the pregnant woman to give that fetus life, if she so chooses to do." I am so happy that Ms. Guinn reveals this little-known fact to us. Who knew that pregnant women give birth to living creatures?

One little teeny correction, however. Once a woman is pregnant, the fetus already has life. Oh, and it takes more than a woman to produce a fetus. You know... a man.

3) "...We as women don’t go around telling men that they need to go have a vasectomy..." Aside from the fact the women DO tell men to go get a vasectomy, it isn't the same thing. A fetus represents the product of conception, not the process. A proper use of this vasectomy comparison would be to a woman's fallopian tubes, not her unborn baby.

Further, no one is telling Ms. Guinn to prevent her pregnancy (in the same manner, a vasectomy prevents a man from being fertile). Just the opposite. Pro-lifers aren't interested in keeping her from being fertile, they are wanting her to continue the process already begun and deliver the life already growing in her.

Perhaps in the horrific pro-life world where mothers would not be allowed to kill their children in utero, a pregnant woman is indeed being forced to do something. Why is this uniquely offensive to abortion advocates? Parents are forced to feed and care for their 2 year old toddler. I am required to feed and care for my dog. A doctor is forced to treat an ill patient. We are all forced to care for the poor via the tax code. A lot of us are being force to do a lot of things for others every day.

And, all of us are required to not injure other parties. A good portion of the law enjoins us from acting in ways that cause damage to others. I suspect Ms. Guinn would generally agree that there should be laws that protect people. I would suggest to Ms. Guinn that where those people happen to be located is not relevant.

4) "Women have all theses rights except the right to do with our body as we please." Um, Ms. Guinn. Abortion is LEGAL. Or are there some other rights involving your body you think you deserve but don't presently possess?

In addition, this statement is false. Neither men nor women can do with their bodies as they please. They cannot ingest illegal drugs, sell themselves for prostitution, or sell their organs. I'm sure Ms. Guinn can think of other examples.

5) "...keep your religious views and morals to yourself." Advice that she apparently is not required to heed herself. After all, she just wrote a letter to the editor expressing her moral outrage that someone would suggest that abortion is wrong.

6) "It’s my uterus and my life!" This narcissistic view is emblematic with what wrong with contemporary society. However, it's her life only to the extent that it doesn't impede or damage other lives. And that is the crux of the matter. There is no question that a pregnant woman's womb contains a life, and there is no dispute that it is genetically human.
---------------

Ms. Guinn is in essence making a property rights argument. We certainly can agree that the fundamental property rights issue is who owns our bodies. In a free society, government has no say in what we legally do with our own property as a matter of unalienable rights. However, these rights are not absolute.

Let's analyze the issue by way of analogy. Suppose you own a property, perhaps a home. As a matter of right, your possession of this property entitles you to make decisions about it unimpeded by government. But the right is not absolute. Your property rights can be and are diminished, often as a matter of law.

For example, when you rent out your property, the rights of those who occupy the property supersede some of your rights. The tenant has property rights, even though it is your property. The tenant has a right to occupy and possess the property. The tenant has an expectation of privacy, of the enjoyment of the property for his legal purposes. He also enjoys the right to be free from arbitrary eviction. All these rights are established by law.

Indeed, in many cities, you cannot refuse to rent to tenants for a variety of reasons, which means that your tenant has a legal right to rent from you even though you might not be a willing participant.

This means you cannot act upon your property rights if the action violates the rights of your tenant. Certainly, you cannot kill your tenant, no matter how unpleasant he may be or how much his presence inconveniences you.

So the key question is, does a fetus possess rights, including property rights? The courts have ruled that the fetus does not have rights, but that does not settle the matter. In the past the courts have ruled that owning slaves is constitutional. The courts do err. I think they have erred in negating the property rights of the unborn child by simply deeming the child "not alive."

This is a legal status, of course. Medically speaking, the fetus is quite alive, and clearly human. True, its does not have the ability to survive outside the womb, but neither does a baby, if left to its own devices. And yes, a fetus is and will be inconvenient. But again, so is a child. And maybe the fetus causes emotional distress. So do children. The only difference between a fetus and a baby that is born is its location.

The fetus' location in the womb means it is owed a duty by its mother to exercise due care to protect the fetus' pre-eminent property rights. A woman, by becoming pregnant, has ceded certain aspects of her own property rights because of the rights of the occupant of her womb. The presence of the fetus diminishes the rights of the woman, and rightly so.

Thursday, June 7, 2012

A friend's conversation with an irrational person

Here is the dialogue. My friend sent this to me with a request for me to comment. My comments are below.
---------------


My friend: Would it be possible for you to remove the two photos of the wine bottles you put on our Facebook page? Makes it look like we are all about booze. I would prefer that we not give the world that impression. Thanks for your help.

R.H.: why? that is part of the ceremony, is the wine???

No.... I will not remove them. They are not photos of anyone drinking from them, one is clearly marked juice, and wine is VERY symbolic in the passover seder. Why be ashamed of having wine at a meal? I see no reason for such, and I have labeled the photos, well, commented on them, to avoid any "confusion" or assumptions.

My friend: Well I am sorry and disappointed to hear that. I would like you to please reconsider. Thanks.

R.H.: I would like to understand why you think it would be offensive to leave it on. I am sorry you see it as something to be ashamed of. Part of the seder is about the wine. The pictures are labeled, there's even juice bottles in the picture, so I am sorry, there's nothing offensive in those photos, so no, I will not reconsider. if you ask me to take those off, then we may as well take all passover photos off, as they ALL contain wine in them. I think this is a bit much.

I could understand if someone was drinking directly from the bottle. But since wine is representational in the seder, AND, in shabbat dinners in general, AND the fact it is normal to have wine at many meals around the world, I see no reason to take it off.

My friend: I don't understand why you responded the way you did. I thought I asked you nicely and I thought my appeal was also done in a kind way. Would you mind praying about this situation, please?

R.H.: I will respond tomorrow. By phone. All my comments are in pleasant conversation tone. Just because you ask nicely, which I knew, or assumed, does not mean you can dictate my response. I believe you wanting me to remove these photos is wrong, amd petty. There is no call for such issue, as there should be no issue with the photos. And, I believe you need to pray about your heart intent, and consider the pics and their comments, and the fact that your wife chose the bottles for wine, juice and water should say somethung also. There is nothing to hide, there is no sin. I will not discuss this here further. I will call you tomorrow. Thank you

My friend: I am not sure why you need to call me.

R.H.: Do you have a reason for not wishing to speak to me, or can hyou consider this issue dropped?

My friend: I consider this issue dropped with you. I sure didn't mean to get you upset.

R.H.: I did not get upset. I was completely calm, I was rather incredulous. I did not appreciate you trying to guilt trip me into changing my mind for something as petty as the photos, which are not inappropriate, and because of your comment, I even made sure to comment on my photos to avoid any confusion. However, what I did not appreciate even more was the fact that aside from the attempt at guilt tripping, when I made clear my intent, and reasons that fully support, you still insisted on using any means possible, "I hope you will pray about this and find that you are wrong", as how that comes across. Now, with that last response that you sent yesterday, then I was a little perturbed. I do hope you can understand my reasoning, and why I will not concede in this matter.

R.H.: I do hope you have a pleasant day, as it is a pleasant day outside. this is the last day of school for us, having a picnic with myd aughter at school, then going to the rodeo, to see if we can catch the Pena kiddo in action again. May the Lord bless you.


-------------------------------


Wow, this woman really goes for the jugular for very inconsequential reasons.

why? that is part of the ceremony, is the wine??? No.... I will not remove them. They are not photos of anyone drinking from them, one is clearly marked juice, and wine is VERY symbolic in the passover seder. Why be ashamed of having wine at a meal? I see no reason for such, and I have labeled the photos, well, commented on them, to avoid any "confusion" or assumptions.

She was hostile from the beginning. Her initial reply contains a flat decline. She uses multiple question marks, which conveys emphasized incredulous astonishment. A presumed value judgment ("Why be ashamed...") that is not contained in your comments. Putting the word "confusion" in quotes, when you didn't use the word.

I will respond tomorrow. By phone. All my comments are in pleasant co.versation tone. Just because you ask nicely, which I knew, or assumed, does not mean you can dictate my response. I believe you wanting me to remove these photos is wrong, amd petty. There is no call for such issue, as there should be no issue with the photos. And, I believe you need to pray about your heart intent, and consider the pics and their comments, and the fact that Jane chose the bottles for wine, juice and water should say somethung also. There is nothing to hide, there is no sin. I will not discuss this here further. I will call you tomorrow.thank you

She escalates the hostility. The use of the word "petty," a charge she repeats later. Where, exactly, did you attempt to dictate her response? She then impugns your motives (heart intent). She wants you to pray about the issue, but she was previously offended by you asking her to pray. (?)

I did not get upset. I was completely calm, I was rather incredulous. I did not appreciate you trying to guilt trip me into changing my mind for something as petty as the photos, which are not inappropriate, and because of your comment, I even made sure to comment on my photos to avoid any confusion. However, what I did not appreciate even more was the fact that aside from the attempt at guilt tripping, when I made clear my intent, and reasons that fully support, you still insisted on using any means possible, "I hope you will pray about this and find that you are wrong", as how that comes across. Now, with that last response that you sent yesterday, then I was a little perturbed. I do hope you can understand my reasoning, and why I will not concede in this matter.

She was incredulous, which means she considers your request to be outlandish and unreasonable. Followed by an unfounded accusation made twice("guilt trip"), which is not justified by anything you said, and a diminution of you ("petty"). Then she misrepresents what you said ("Would you mind praying about this situation, please" is morphed into "I hope you will pray about this and find that you are wrong").

I would give this woman a wide berth. She is not rational, and seems to feel free to impute to people the most insidious of ulterior motives, especially when someone disagrees with her, even over minor issues.

Tuesday, June 5, 2012

Obama didn't create the debt: FB conversation

S.B. posted this: Wait. you mean Obama DIDN'T create all the debt single handedly? Who knew?




US Economic Information
Illustrations of US economic information

Me: Most informed people do know. That is, the House has the specified authority in the Constitution to appropriate money. It is also worth noting that Obama as Senator voted for every one of the stimulus bills.

By the way, I note that Obama is trumpeting his "achievement" of saving the country via stimulus spending. So is the debt inflicted good or bad? I guess it's just abouit which narrative is being pressed, eh?

R.Y.: A good lesson in the dangers of compound interest on debt, too.

R.R.: Finally something he can blame on his predecessors! ;-)

C.K.: ‎@ Rich, do you really think the stimulus bills are the primary source of spending increases under Reagan, Bush 1 and W?

Me: C.K., I made no such assertion.

C.K.: Then why would it matter how Obama voted on the stimulus packages? I think he is on record in believing that in times of economic crisis, stimulus can be effective. Funny the Republicans used to believe that also.

R.Y.: In fact, I believe we had a Republican president the last time Obama was able to vote on a stimulus package.

Me: Because Obama as Senator voted for the spending that added to the national debt.The graph shifts spending to Bush II's last budget year as if Obama had no part to play in its creation. The original premise: you mean Obama DIDN'T create all the debt single handedly?

I don't have any interest in what Republicans believe, since I am not one. Their stupidity and profligate spending does not justify the actions of democrats.

R.E.: But what about a Democratic Congress and Senate. With a Dem President at the helm.

R.Y.: Frankly I believe that any time you get single-party control of both the legislative and executive branches you'll end up with runaway spending.

C.K.: ‎"Because Obama as Senator voted for the spending that added to the national debt" But you just admitted that it was not a significant driver of the debt. It may have actually paid for itself. Meanwhile the tax cut that Bush put into place was actually greater than the deficit in 2007.

C.K.: No tax cut and 2007 ends in a surplus.

Me: I did not admit that. The stimuli were unmitigated disasters.

If the stimuli paid for themselves, then why did the national debt go from $9.2 trillion in '08 to $15.2 trillion in'12?

C.K.: How much were those stimulus packages again? How much was spending and how much was tax-cuts?

C.K.: ‎@ Rich, do you really think the stimulus bills are the primary source of spending increases under Reagan, Bush 1 and W? You seemed to say no.

M.D.: I don't think you understand what we are up against. Its not a republican or a democrat issue.Its the puppet masters above them tied to the British empire that are padding there greedy little pockets.This government is completely defacto.The structure of government that we have is called an Oligarchy where a select few of the wealthiest control us.This country was formed as a republic which is limited gov under the checks and balances of the constitution and we the people are there employers not the other way around.Democracy is where 51% of the people decide whats best for every one and that doesn't work because the rich own the air ways and the news papers and can spread propaganda witch sways the votes there way with lies and trickery.That is why we excepted a central bank,read the book monster from jackal island.If you want to learn more go to www.republicfortheunitedstates.org

The year 1776 marked America’s victory in the war for independence. The lawful... right to re-inhabit is inherent in The Declaration of Independence circa 1776. The Declaration, one of our founding documents, declares our right to change, alter or abolish any system of government that we believe is ...See More

Me: Of course I said no. The first stimulus was signed into law on February 13, 2008. Reagan died in 2004 and Bush I has been out of office for nearly 20 years.

The national debt increased as follows:

2008: $9.210, 24.2% increase over prior year
09: 10.628, 13.3%
10: 12.290, 13.5%
11: 13.998, 12.2%
12: 15.226, 8%

C.K.: Okay then was it a significant driver of the increase in spending under Bush 2, which was part of the question.

Me: If I may correct you, it was a significant driver of spending under a democratic congress.

C.K.: W only had a Democratic congress in 2007 and 2008.

C.K.: He also has the power to veto.

Me: Again, I have no intention of defending big spending republicans. Bush II was wrong to support the stimuli. But again, all appropriations arise in the House. The fact that Bush II agreed is not relevant.

Me: ‎2008 and 2009 spending was controlled by a democratic house, and Obama voted in favor in the senate. Yes, bush had a democratic congress in 2007 and 2008, which is when the crisis happened and spending spree intensified.

Me: Yes, bush had a democratic congress in 2007 and 2008, which is when the crisis happened and spending spree intensified.

Me: Back to the original premise...

No not so much. Remember spending in 2007 was approved before the Dems took office. 2008 was the bail-out that could have been avoided if Bush was not so dogmatic.

C.K.: Still waiting for you to tell me what percentage of that increased spending was the result of stimulus.

Me: The fiscal policy of the last 30 years culminated in the financial crisis. It could not have been avoided; indeed, they are doubling down on the policies that caused the problem.

C.K.: I think it could have been avoided if steps were taken to prevent the foreclosure crisis from occurring in the first place. They saw that one coming as early as 2006 and did nothing, because the benevolent free hand of the market and all that malarkey. The policies that caused the problem are the very prescription that the Republicans are suggesting to fix the crisis.

Me: Unfortunately, the nature of your question is based on a flawed premise, i.e., that the economy is a closed system where a change in one area does not affect other areas. The stimuli are not isolated events. The implementation of them affected the money supply, the lending practices of banks, the holders of debt of Chevrolet and Chrysler, the confidence of consumers, the hiring activities of employers, the amount of tax revenue coming to the treasury because of unemployment, the amount of S.S. disability claims as people looked for ways to find income, the value of homes and retirement accounts. There is a wide and varied fallout from the decisions government has made.

C.K.: Now you are talking in circles and cannot back up your claims with facts. In other words you do not know the answer.

Me: The original premise of the post. He is not only a part of the problem, but complicit in the mess.

Me: It seems rather plain to me. Government intervention creates a ripple effect throughout the economy. This is basic economics. A trillion spent in various stimuli has a 10 fold ripple effect through the economy.

Me: As long as we agree theat Obama inherited the mess and is not to blame for the subsequent 3 1/2 years.

C.K.: Yes it does create a ripple effect. Much of it positive.

http://www.democracynow.org/2012/5/17/end_this_depression_now_paul_krugman



Public spending is under assault from the United States to Europe in the name of... fighting deficits. Nobel Prize-winning economist Paul Krugman argues in his new book, "End This Depression Now!", that the hysteria over the deficit will constrain an economic recovery in a time of high unemployment and...

Me: Are you perhaps going to answer any of my questions?

Me: Krugman? OMG. try again.

C.K.: You have not made a single non-declarative statement

C.K.: How many nobel prizes do you have in economics?

Me: Zero, and no peace prizes either. Of course, I don't brag about killing Osama either.

C.K.: Because you didn't.

Me: Zing.

Me: Looking around for the positive ripple effect. Still looking.

Me:  ‎"If the stimuli paid for themselves, then why did the national debt go from $9.2 trillion in '08 to $15.2 trillion in'12?"
C.K.:  You know what? This sarcasm is not going to make this conversation productive. The CBO stated that the stimulus saved or produced 3 million jobs. Before the stimulus we were losing 100's of thousands of jobs per month. We have had successive quarters of GDP growth and American corporations recorded record profits. You cannot see what you refuse to see.
C.K.: "If the stimuli paid for themselves, then why did the national debt go from $9.2 trillion in '08 to $15.2 trillion in'12?" Was the stimulus $3 trillion? Could it be a war that was unpaid for, a tax cut that was unpaid for. How can you begin to prove that the stimulus was a negative factor and caused this deficit? You need to prove cause and effect. 

C.K.: Now I am out and you can have the last word.

Monday, June 4, 2012

legislating global warming - FB Conversation


S.B. posted this: FrickIng amazing.



North Carolina tries to outlaw sea level rise grist.org
North Carolina is no stranger to the “if you dislike it then you should have made a law against it” model of legislation, but this is extreme: The state General Assembly’s Replace...

T.R.:  ONLY in a RED STATE...

R.E.: If you read the text of the of the Bill I can understand where they are going with this.

S.B.: Where is that, R.E.? A complete disregard for science?

R.E.: What it is saying is who will Government listen to make determination as to changes in use of coastal lands such as permits and regulations requirements. They are not disregarding science at all but which sciencist do you listen to and which Model do we use. That is what they are saying. How do we make the Determination as a state to cause more uniform regulation of the use of coastal lands.
S.B.: Nonsense. They are saying "DESPITE significant scientific consensus on the range of ocean level predictions, we choose to prescribe ones that nobody actually believes and which have absolutely no methodological basis on which to rest -- because those are the ones that serve our political purposes."
S.B.: Responsible planning would take into account the range of scientific opinion on this -- in which case their prediction would be FAR on the low-end of any credible prediction -- and require developers to plan accordingly. Which is precisely what Disney did, for example, in planning a $5B seaside resort in China recently -- they brought in climate scientists to help them understand what the likely (not "hoped for") scenarios would be, and planned their resort on the basis of the best science available at the time. This action by the NC legislature is an insult to the scientific process and a mockery of the planning process.

S.B.: I can't spare the time to try to explain all of climate science to you. Go educate yourself before trying to get into this debate -- and you'll realize there's very little to debate. This is not about "getting any scientist to say anything" -- the models on which more realistic sea level rises are predicted are far from arbitrary, and represent a broad consensus of the scientific community. Linear extrapolation of recent historical data IS a completely arbitrary approach -- there's no scientific basis for using that approach, and few in the scientific community feel that it would have any relevance to making science-based predictions of sea level increase. Linear extrapolation. Many, many phenomena in the environment are non-linear, and sea level rise appears to be one of them.

On what scientific basis do you argue that the linear method makes any sense? Where's a citation to research that suggests it has any relevance?

S.B.: like i said -- the disdain for science in this country -- particularly among the right, but really it's more universal than that, is extremely disheartening to anyone who cares about science.
R.E.: or it deciding that a county cant decide to use coastal lands just to develop lands just for additional tax revenue. Which has happened in the past. By the state deciding the criteria you use coastal land it doesn't allow for the County government to make that determination. As someone who lived in North Carolina I know how the counties will suddenly decide to develop an area of wet land regardless of the damage it will do to nature. They want to have proven models and not just someone with a PHD behind thier name to say what they think about some unproven therory. They are trying to give a baseline for the Scienctist and evidence to how the coastal lands are to be used. And there is no place in the Bill that says they are going hold back the sea rising?

S.B.: Don't quit your day job 

R.E.: As far as Climate Change, There a basically three thereories out there 1. It is a natural occurence and is uneffected by man. 2. It is caused by man thru green house gasses. 3 It is a Natural occurrence that is effected by man thru green house gasses. There is compelling evidence on all three thereories. One has to decide which one you want to believe in. Trust me Scott I've done my reading on this subject.

S.B.: Rod if you think those theories are on equal scientific footing there's nothing I can say that will change your mind on the matter. Other than keep reading.
Me: It ain't a disdain for sceince. That is trotted out whenever someone disagrees with leftist prescriptions. 

S.B.: Ok. Maybe "disdain" is too strong a word. "ignorance" might be better - as in the act of deliberately ignoring it 

R.Y.: It is, however, a flat out denial of observed trends to increase short-term private profits. In the long term the costs of such denial will then be passed on to the taxpayers. 

L.F.: What I find disturbing is the "Science is a conspiracy AGAINST progress!!!" mentality. Yes... Right... The brave few who go in to science anymore surely do it to get rich by cheating the common man out of his rightful wealth. 

Me: The problem is the left constantly moralizing about it. Science has nothing to do with this. It is the insistence on big government solutions when it is clear that government solutions are anything but.

It is one thing to discern a situation/problem. It is quite another to insist on the process of remedy and degrade one's political opponents if they dare open their mouths.

And no, it isn't about money, it's about power. 

R.E.: To tell me to keep reading On which scienctific model do you think I should be subscribing to because if you notice as far as the science I didn't really take a side, you just read more into it than I was saying. I was taking the side on th...e control of the use of coastal land being at the state level rather than local Government because of making it more uniform. As far as Climate change you do realize that the science community doesn't all agree on which model they subscribe to and there is good arguements on all three possible causes, I know which one I do subscribe to. Scott since you have been calling me an idiot on this posting why don't you tell me which one I subscribe to.

B.R.: I propose another theory to the climate debate: physics. We generally agree on how physics works, and the distinct lack of a left or right spin on anything seems trustworthy. 

R.E.: How do you propose to use physics to forecast future tidal action and weather patterns? Un like the West Coast and especially Washington State, We don't have violent weather than can hit North Carolina.

Friday, June 1, 2012

Atheist Sam Harris' book, "Free Will"

Atheist Sam Harris, from his latest book Free Will: "Certain beliefs place their adherents beyond the reach of every peaceful means of persuasion, while inspiring them to commit acts of extraordinary violence against others." And, ""Some propositions are so dangerous that it may even be ethical to kill people for believing them."

So, the beliefs that he finds dangerous are those that inspire people to commit violence against others. He apparently believes that it is ethical to kill people for beliefs that inspire them to commit violence against others.

Yet he holds the belief that committing violence against others is ethical, based on what they believe

To paraphrase: It is ethical to kill people whose beliefs make them want to kill people. My belief is that it is ethical to kill people.

Wednesday, May 23, 2012

What you will likely be taught in college

  • America is a deeply flawed nation and must be understood and characterized in this context. It is fundamentally a nation defined by slavery, discrimination against women, genocidal policies toward the indigenous population, unjustified foreign wars, homophobia and persecution of minorities.
  • America’s unrestrained capitalism is unfair; it benefits the rich at the expense of the poor, it creates and exacerbates poverty, it facilitates the exploitative behavior of unscrupulous corporations, and needlessly subjects the economy to convulsive upheavals such as the 2008 crash.
  • America not only ignores environmental concerns, it is the worst offender. It is hopelessly addicted to fossil fuels.
  • America was not built on Judeo-Christian religious principles, and few if any of the Founders were Christians. In fact, Christianity perpetrates genocide and hatred, and as such it is no longer appropriate or acceptable in a tolerant and diverse society. Christianity needs to be removed from public life in favor of a secular, humanist ethic built on understanding and social justice.
  • There is no real American culture; American exceptionalism is a myth. America was built on diverse peoples, and their values and cultural history are of equal merit.
  • The Constitution is a product of a an earlier time, when things were much different. The Founders could not anticipate what modern society would be like. therefore, it is antiquated and of limited value.
  • The notion of rugged individualism is a cowboy mentality and has no place in an enlightened society. We are interdependent, and no one is of greater value than another. We therefore need the guidance of a benevolent and powerful government to wisely chart a proper course for us and correct the deficiencies of our economic and cultural condition. 

Thursday, May 17, 2012

How long was Jesus dead?

Recently we've been reconsidering many of the things we thought we understood regarding doctrine and faith. We have begun to question certain beliefs, church structures, and practices of the western church. Too often we have discovered unbiblical doctrines and activities. This causes us concern. We have deemed this our “Rethink.”

Our questions include, how did we arrive at our doctrines? Does the Bible really teach what we think it teaches? Why do churches do what they do? What is the biblical basis of church leadership structure? Why do certain traditions get entrenched?

It's easy to be spoon fed the conventional wisdom, but it's an entirely separate thing to search these things out for one's self. In the past we have read the Bible with these unexamined understandings and interpreted what we read through those lenses. We were lazy about our Bible study, assuming that pastors and theologians were telling us the truth, but we rarely checked it out for ourselves. 

Therefore, these Rethinks are our attempt to remedy the situation. We should note that we are not Bible scholars, but we believe that one doesn't need to be in order to understand the Word of God.

Wednesday, May 16, 2012

Will we rebel against unjust laws?

Much has been said about the ever-increasing oppressiveness of government. Some have compared it to the revolutionary era, when brave men made brave decisions about the oppression they faced. Many died, and out of that rebellion was birthed a nation, conceived in liberty. These people believe that a new rebellion may soon come.

Others have said that the laws of this nation must be obeyed, because we are a nation of laws. The government is in authority over us and we need to submit to that authority. Any talk of civil disobedience is repugnant to them.

Let me ask this. Who is it that is actually rebelling? Our Constitution is the highest law of the land. This document creates, defines, and limits government. That is its sole purpose. If anyone violates the Constitution, and does it regularly and with impunity, are they not rebels? You know, like congress, the courts, and the president?

Rebellion. The rebel is not the one who believes in and adheres to the Constitution. The rebel is the one who disregards it and negates it. The rebel is the one who explains away the clear language of our founding document and substitutes their own pop culture rationalizations.

Might we reasonably determine that much of the federal government is in rebellion when they refuse to support and defend the tenets of the very document that gives them their authority?

Our response? I think the TEA party has it right. Support candidates who will defend and obey the Constitution as written, hold representatives' feet to the fire when they are in office, and vote them out if they violate their oath of office.

I hope there will never come a day when government inters dissenters. I hope that Christians will never have to choose between jail and their faith. I hope that defenders of the Constitution will never be branded as traitors for failing to toe the political line.

But, we will see.

Tuesday, May 15, 2012

Gender and insurance pricing - editorial

Since Montana’s unisex insurance law is back to the forefront this campaign season, perhaps it would be profitable to deal with some of the issues raised.

Some of you may not know that Montana law forbids insurance companies from charging women a different rate than men. Advocates for the law believe it is discriminatory to base insurance pricing on gender. And they are right. Every decision an insurance company makes is discrimination.

Unfortunately, the word “discrimination” has been redefined to be synonymous with “bigotry.” I suppose this is because the emotional content is useful as an opinion manipulator. Generic discrimination, however, is much more innocuous. Every choice is discriminatory. Since choice is informed by a variety of factors, some kinds of discrimination are correct and proper while other kinds may be bigoted and malevolent.

Someone recently suggested that “insurance discrimination” (that is, gender specific insurance pricing) is of the latter kind, and as a result insurance companies get more profit. This is incorrect. Insurance prices are determined by statistical analysis of losses, to which profit and overhead are added. That total does not change simply because it’s being allocated differently. In other words, the total dollar figure is the same, even though some customers pay less than others.

Insurance companies love to crunch numbers. They have found that certain kinds of attributes have poorer claims experience and therefore should priced higher. I think most of us would agree with this. We want insurance companies to discriminate. We expect them to. Those of us who drive carefully, or take good care of our houses or health, rightly believe we ought to be rewarded with lower insurance rates. People with health problems should pay more for their life and health insurance policies. Someone with a DUI or an accident should pay higher auto rates than a driver with a perfect record.

But despite the fact there are differences in loss experience for men and women, Montana law forbids the use of gender. Even though women utilize health insurance more than men, they pay less because of unisex. Women have lower mortality rates than men, but unisex means they pay more for life insurance coverage. Unisex means that women pay more for car insurance, even though they tend to have fewer claims than men.

We also need to note that unisex itself impacts insurance rates. Montana is a sparsely populated state, certainly not a huge profit center for insurance companies. They can sell easily more policies in Seattle than in the entire state of Montana. This means that fewer insurance companies choose to do business here, which lessens competition. Also, insurance companies will have higher administrative costs to make their pricing conform to Montana statute. So to some degree, the unisex law itself increases our rates.

So insurance companies are not eeevil. Really. Corporations are legal constructs, they are not people. And corporations, by the way, do not have free speech rights like people do. Therefore I resist the attempts to anthropomorphize corporations and then demonize them.

Ok, despite all this, I agree with unisex insurance. This may shock some of you, knowing that I’m an insurance agent. But consider: Do you suppose there might be a difference in insurance loss experience between gays and straights? Blacks and whites? Christians and atheists? I actually don’t know if there is, and I’ll bet that insurance companies don’t know either. Why? Because it would be unacceptable to price a product based on factors like these, regardless of any statistical justification.

So this all means there is no real financial incentive for insurance companies to employ gender specific insurance rates, but there might be for Montanans. However, societal issues are also important. Unisex insurance simply means that we have decided it is worth paying the price for excluding gender in insurance pricing.

I happen to agree.

Friday, May 11, 2012

Government needs to help stop obesity - FB conversation


R.W. posted this: Fat people will soon be illegal!



newsbusters.org
"Touting new recommendations from an Institute of Medicine panel on obesity on Tuesday's NBC Nightly News, science correspondent Robert Bazell proclaimed to viewers: "...a sea change in how we perceive obesity. No longer a question of individual responsibility, but

a need to change what's called an... "

K.C.: ‎. . . so whatever happened to that underground railroad?

B.R.: wah wah wah

R.W.: it's still there but now makes regular stops at the DQ

R.W.: You don't have to worry B.R., but the rest of us .......

B.R.: how dare the government give underperforming parents a hand, cry liberty my god!

Me: I'm so glad we have the government to tell us who is underperforming as parents.

B.R.: I can tell you myself: any parent whose child is obese for no medical reason is underperforming. It's not rocket science, it's called caring about the health of your kids.

Me: And that makes it a matter for the federal government.

R.W.: B.R. , when you have a child, I will send over the government inspectors to make sure you are conforming to the guidlines established by an all knowing government. The same government that gave the indians such fair treatment, that allowed s...lavery for centuries, that prohibited women the vote. Those same people will now teach us how to raise our children. Maybe it is best if we just turned over our offspring the way the Chinese do.

B.R.: Man, isn't it easier to jump to inane exaggerations than to try and solve a national epidemic?

Me: National epidemic? Now that's hyperbole itself. Help us, O great government!

R.W.: Do you want ANY decisions to be made by yourself? Or do you look to big brother to solve ALL your problems.

B.R.: They're not coming into Americans' homes, they're in the public schools, where kids learn many things that their overworked, underpaid parents don't have the time or attention to. School is good. Health is good. Exercise is good. Everything else is bitching.

B.R.: I'll take the goverment's help and thank them. I was a welfare baby.

Me: We don't need no education; we don't need no thought control; teachers, leave those kids alone.

B.R.: Also, my kids will be in very good shape, because I care enough to make sure it happens.

Me: Stupid parents. Who needs them?

R.W.: So YOU don't need the government to tell you how to reaise YOUR kids but your neighbors DO?

R.W.: If I give my kids ice cream should I be punished?

B.R.: I do need the government actually, to help me and my future kids stay in good health, good economic standing, and good awareness of the world around me. Look, if you're going to blindly stick to the moral that "government can't tell me how ...to live my life", you're going to miss out on a lot of really helpful and vital things. R.W., your kids are all beautiful and in good shape, at least last time I saw a family photo. But some parents let their kids get obese. And that's a form of abuse. And that's where the government can help, by making sure that public schools are a place where kids (both abused and not) can get what they NEED. Look at that word: NEED. Kids need good food and exercise. NEEEEEEEED. If they're not getting it at home, they get obese. It doesn't matter if the parents are intentionally letting them get obese, or if the parents are just pieces of crap who don't know how to care for a helpless little person. KIDS NEED GOOD FOOD AND EXERCISE.

Me: Ergo, we neeeeeeeed government because people neeeeeeed things. Yup.

R.W.: Maybe there should be a parenting test! You get a license to breed if you qualify. Obese parents will certainly raise obese children so they are out. And school will have to be 16 hours long, because you just KNOW when those kids get hom...e, they are going to play video games. The government will have to limit television broadcast to two hours a day then it can only be NEWS. We wil have money because BUS service just leads to laziness so that's out. In fact, I think there should only be 1 chair in a house and people can sit in shifts.

B.R.: Oh, ok. Willful ignorance. Nevermind then.

R.W.: B.R. , you are saying that WITHOUT government you can NOT be in good health, good economic standing or be aware of the world around you. How do you think people managed before the government got so large? How did you get THROUGH the depression and other hard times? We helped each other as NEIGHBORS not as a government institution. WE fended for ourselves a lot more. WE looked to our churches. You are a smart healthy man. Stand up for yourself and be a strong independent MAN instead of one that needs to be coddled like a child.

B.R.: You're taking a complex world and bottling it into your own limited experience, man.

R.W.: I didn't mean YOU got through the depression but the country.

Me: Yeah, R.W.. You are thinking too small. Come one, dude. Become a believer in all powerful government.

R.W.: B.R., our country is great because of the INDIVIDUALS in it. Not because we have to best bureaucracy.

B.R.: ‎R.W., our country is great and millions of its citizens are obese and malnourished. If those people want to disregard their own health by denying the government's assistance, that's their right as Americans. But if they disregard their childrens' health, which is what they do when they let their kids get and remain obese, then they are abusing their children. The government won't come into their homes to keep them from abusing their children, because that's denying the INDIVIDUALS' right to privacy. But if those shitty parents are sending their abused obese children to public schools, then the government (local AND federal) has a say in a) what their lunch room serves, b) what exercise is included in the required Physical Education classes, and c) what values and lessons those kids are taught in their classrooms. What about this doesn't make sense to you?

Me: Obesity = abuse? Abuse = government intervention? Absolute nonsense.

B.R.: It's like you're intentionally trying to not get my point. Let's slow this down:

Yes, letting your kids get and remain obese is ABUSE. It's unhealthy for them. It's the same as letting them eat paint, or go years without brushing their tee...th, or letting play with dangerous tools. It's extremely neglectful and can do nothing except harm them.

No, abuse does not mean government intervention, that's what I covered when I said "The government won't come into their homes to keep them from abusing their children, because that's denying the INDIVIDUALS' right to privacy." The government is already in the public school, that's what public school is. The government is currently reacting to the medical news about how dangerous and widespread obesity is. Are they reacting in a way that takes away your rights? No. They're talking about using the public schools, which they're already involved in, to make school a healthier place for kids of all sizes.

Me: No, I think I understand your point. You're not seeming to get mine. This obesity thing is a created crisis being used as an excuse to capitalize on an opportunity to further insert external influences into places they've never been before. This is new ground.

The original point R.W. made is that generic obesity is portrayed as a public problem, one that government wants to address. You have taken a subset of that (fat children) and are justifying government intervention by labelling it abuse when you can't know that it is abuse.

If government can force someone, anyone, to lose weight, their rights are being violated. A child has the same rights as adults, including a right to be secure in their persons and property. Government does not have the authority to violate that.

R.W.: WHO determines OBESE. Who defines abuse. Who gets to say what Healthy is. There are already communities telling private business's what they can NOT serve, and what they MUST serve. The government does not have the right to go through your PERSONAL lunch to inspect it even if it IS in school. The government has ALREADY crossed the line. The government does not know the meaning of the word restraint, or common sense.

B.R.: So both of you are seeing this issue mainly in terms of the government's role in citizens' lives, and I'm seeing this issue in terms of how government can help kids be healthy when their parents have failed to do so. We're not going to get much further than this, but thank you both for reiterating your points, I think they're both valid and worthy of future discussion.

Me: A magnanimous reply. One last point. They government has never solved a social problem yet, so it seems unreasonable to assume that they could help kids be healthy.

R.W.: wait, Poverty is ended right? I mean we spent like 4 trillions dollars on it! Surely we solved THAT problem.

B.R.: Okay, let's say I drop the idea of schools helping kids exercise and eat healthier. How do we react to the new facts, that 2/3 of Americans, and that 1/3 of children, are overweight or obese? What do we do as free Americans?

Me: Interesting question. Or to rephrase, how do we get Americans to reject the cultural rot that glues them to their TVs and video games, the narcisissm of the me-first attitude, the idea that government will solve all my problems so I don't have to do a thing?

We have to accurately assess the cause before we can effect a cure. I would suggest that government has contributed to our descent down this road by making the lives of people insulated from the perils of life. If there is no risk there is no reward and there is no point in doing anything.

Public schools are all about self esteem now. Never have so many students felt so good about their own mediocrity.

Tuesday, May 8, 2012

God loves everyone - FB Conversation

My FB friend J.S. posted this: ‎"You can safely assume you've created God in your own image when it turns out that God hates all the same people you do." ~Beth Moore

Me: Who does God hate?

J.S.: Exactly the point..God hates no one. Thats why I am created in His image and He is not created in mine. Which let me tell you is a pretty good thing...LOL

Me: What do you think of Psalms 5:5, Psalms 11:5, Prov 6:16-19, Hosea 9:15, and Mal 1:2-3?

Ps. 11:5 The LORD examines the righteous, but the wicked and those who love violence his soul hates.

Pr. 6:16-19 There are six things the LORD hates, seven that are detestable to him: haughty eyes, a lying tongue, hands that shed innocent blood, a heart that devises wicked schemes, feet that are quick to rush into evil, a false witness who pours out lies and a man who stirs up dissension among brothers.

Ho. 9:15 “Because of all their wickedness in Gilgal, I hated them there. Because of their sinful deeds, I will drive them out of my house. I will no longer love them; all their leaders are rebellious.

Mal. 1:3 Yet I have loved Jacob, but Esau I have hated, and I have turned his mountains into a wasteland and left his inheritance to the desert jackals.

J.S.: God hates evil and hates many things that many people possess (including myself, I have things inside that God hates)...but I don't think God hates people. Do you think God hates people Rich?

Me: What do the Scriptures say? What's your take on them?

E.H.: I don't think the point is if God loves or hates people I think the point that needs to be focused on is we all could love more than we do. We could all be more Christ like. And god calls us to love unconditionally. Pointless to get hung up on the details, Beth moore is simply trying to get everyone to take a long hard look in the mirror and start loving as a first reaction instead of a earned feeling for others.

Me: Quite right, E.H. Wise words. However, I do want the Scriptures to be our understanding when it comes to talking about God, not what Beth Moore or anyone else says about Him.

B.S.: Romans 5:8 ESV "but God shows his love for us in that while we were still sinners, Christ died for us."

John 3:16 ESV "For God so loved the world, that he gave his only Son, that whoever believes in him should not perish but have eternal life."

B.S.: God loves everyone fortunately for me He chose not to leave me in my sin condition that He does hate, but the fact that He still came for me in spite of my condition breaks my heart for Him everyday!

Me: Are we engaging in a dispute? I don't want that. But again, what do you think of Psalms 5:5, Psalms 11:5, Prov 6:16-19, Hosea 9:15, and Mal 1:2-3?

B.S.: I feel those verses refer to a sin condition not individual souls. I'm curious, what is your take? Otherwise why did Jesus come?

Me: Just when I think I understand God...

Me: But it is also clear that God is referring to certain specific people that He hates. Esau, for example. He hated those in Gilgal because of their wickedness. His soul hates those who love violence. Wow.

Me: I must always be in a position to challenge my assumptions about things. It is the Holy Spirit who brings understanding.

Does God hate? Clearly he does. Does hate mean what we think it does? Probably not. Does God hate only sin? In a sense, yes. Sin rises a stench before God, whereas worship is a pleasing thing. One might say that sin is the opposite of worship. Sorta.

Me: But what is this hate? Is it like we think of hate? I don't think so. But on the other hand, what would the response be of a holy God when presented with sin? The Father turned away from the Son when He was hanging on the cross. That's something else that I don't understand.

B.S.: In the Hebrew as well as the Greek that word only means loved less.

Me: Looking up Strong's, it's the same word (8804, to hate, be hateful) used in all cases, as is Gen.37:4, for example, referring to specific hate. The original reference to Esau, which is Gen 27:41 (8799, to hate, oppose oneself to, bear a grudge, retain animosity against, cherish animosity against) is a different word.

In Romans 9:13, the verse about Esau is quoted (3404, to hate, pursue with hatred, detest).

Me: I find it interesting that Paul seems to be addressing what we are talking about here. He continues, "What then shall we say? Is God unjust? Not at all! For he says to Moses, “I will have mercy on whom I have mercy, and I will have compassion on whom I have compassion.” And, presumably, He will hate whom He hates. He hates because of sin. He is grieved by hard hearts. He is merciful and comes to judge. I think our problem is that we try to make things into a binary equation (i.e., if God loves, how can He hate), but the Hebrew mind does not work that way. Western thought is binary, and God isn't.

Me: If Hate means Love Less, I'd like to know your source. I am enjoying the conversation, by the way.


‎B.S.: 3404 miséō – properly, to detest (on a comparative basis); hence, denounce; to love someone or something less than someone (something) else, i.e. to renounce one choice in favor of another

B.S.: I am sorry I didn't think this was going to get so long winded, I think if you look at the original quote it never says God doesn't hate people. All she was trying to say was that people have a tendency to assume God views people they way we view them. I think it would be more important for us to try and figure out how we can practically reach the lost rather than try and figure out if God just hates them or not. 2 Timothy 2:16 I think nails where this conversation is heading as much fun as it has been.

Me: This is leading to godless chatter, wandering away from the truth? Really? B.S., that's a terrible thing to say.

Monday, May 7, 2012

A response to my email to my pastor

I sent an email to my pastor, which you can read on May 1st blog entry. I also copied it to Jim Tharp, who was my first pastor when we moved to Bozeman in 1990. Here's Jim's reply:



Rich,

Ah! My dear brother, thank you for sharing your faith -- your optimism, hope, anticipation -- about what God is going to do! I share this hope, and believe with you that we who pray should allow the Spirit to come upon our praying with a greater confidence in being heard when we ask for Great and Mighty things, Demonstrations of His Spirit in power, Outpourings of the Holy Spirit.
I, too, believe we should have some "All-night prayer meetings," and will make the proposals to the Fremonts, McMurrays, Hostlers, Marian and others beyond our normal group. Thank you, brother! What an encouragement your email is. So delighted to hear of a "breakthrough" spiritually for your dear wife.

May God bless you both!

With much love and appreciation,

Pastor Jim Tharp

Monday, April 30, 2012

Obama's campaign themes for 2012 - By Wynton Hall

I thought this was a good analysis, so I posted in in full from newsbusters.org: 

So far, we’ve seen President Obama’s reelection team telegraph five central campaign “themes.”  None of them has anything to do with his record as president, and all of them are nonstarters that are easily refuted by the facts:

1. Mitt Romney is “too rich” to be president. Mitt Romney’s net worth is almost identical ($250 million) to the Democratic Party’s 2004 nominee, John Kerry ($240 million). If Democrats had no problem with a rich guy running for president in 2004, why now?

2. President Obama killed Osama bin Laden: Romney might not have. The Navy SEALS, not Barack Obama, killed Osama bin Laden.  To suggest otherwise is an insult to their bravery and valor. Besides, does any serious person honestly believe that any president--of either party--would not have pulled the trigger when informed that Osama bin Laden was in the cross-hairs? Really?

3. Young people will vote for President Obama again because he is “cooler” than Romney, as is evidenced by his appearances on Jimmy Fallon. College-age voters are over "cool." They want jobs and can’t find them.  One out of every two college graduates will soon hit the Obama economy’s wall of reality and join the growing ranks of the unemployed.  Romney may not be “cool,” but he looks like that family friend mom and dad said to go see because his successful company is hiring. Put simply, Romney may not be the “iPod President,” but he sure looks like the “Paycheck President.” And that’s very cool.

4. President Obama is fighting those evil meany Republicans and their “War on Women.” The Obama economy has been a disaster for female employment. Nine out of ten jobs lost under Obama belonged to women. Female voters are over the “hope and change.” They have kids to feed and family budgets to balance.  They want to work and earn higher wages. Obama has failed to produce either.

5. President Obama grew up poor and therefore has more compassion and willingness to maintain the social safety net. President Obama’s parents were professors, hardly a destitute upbringing (the Washington Post says Stanley Ann Dunham Soetoro, Obama’s mother, made what would today be a $123,000 salary—a figure that would place her in the top six percent of all individual income earners).  Romney’s millions of dollars in private charity donations more than demonstrate that he cares deeply about those in need.  In 2010, Romney donated 14 percent of his income to charity. Vice President Joe Biden? An embarrassing 1.4 percent. In fact, it was only recently that President Obama upped his charitable giving.  Before running for president, the Obamas gave just 6.1 percent to charity.  They've since upped their charitable giving to match Romney’s 14 percent. 

Bottom line: if Obama wants to win reelection, his campaign team has some serious work to do. The five themes they’ve telegraphed thus far are easily refuted by the facts.

Thursday, April 19, 2012

Cohabitation - Fail

Regarding this article on cohabitation in the New York Times, Vox Day is exactly right:

"My thinking is that cohabitation presents an intrinsically false model for marriage because it represents the reverse of the structural power relationship within modern marriage. In a cohabitating relationship, the man usually holds the structural upper hand and the woman's behavior is relatively submissive because she knows he can end it at any time without any significant cost to himself.

Once the marriage takes place, the power balance shifts heavily towards the women thanks to the current divorce laws and her behavior tends to change significantly whether she realizes it or not. Even if she is a genuinely committed wife who is totally unwilling to abuse, or even take advantage of, her legally superior position, she is much less likely to be operating with a mindset of pleasing her husband in order to persuade him to continue the relationship because she no longer needs to be concerned about the possibility of the relationship being easily ended without substantial cost.

This is why couples who cohabitate successfully cannot reasonably assume that the comfortable living arrangements they have made will survive the structural shock to the relationship that takes place after marriage. In fact, the more comfortably the couple cohabitates pre-marriage, the more likely it is that they will have serious problems once the legal aspects of that relationship change with the wedding.

One can certainly make a reasonable case for cohabitation as a substitute for marriage, but the evidence suggests that it is unwise to consider cohabitation a precursor to it."



Wednesday, April 18, 2012

Keeping Social Security out of Wall Street's hands - The Nation hyperventilates again

The Nation Magazine's latest email has a hard time with the facts. Even the title misrepresents the situation. The Nation doesn't want to keep Social Security out of Wall Street's hands, they want to keep it out of the hands of you and me. They are against choice.

Also, it is worth noting that even if some of Social Security was privatized, there is no requirement that the money be invested in "Wall Street." People could invest anywhere.

The Nation says that with privatization the "returns would not be guaranteed, as they are now." This is a bit of rhetorical slight-of-hand, since presently there is no return at all. The Social Security Trust Fund is the receptacle for all Social Security monies the government receives. Upon receipt, the government issues payment to the various payees, and whatever is left over is transferred to the general fund by means of a bond sale, bonds that only the government can buy and sell. These special bonds are issued to the trust fund, and the cash is moved to the general fund.

Yes, these bonds pay interest, which comes, of course, from the general fund. Are you catching the shell game going on here? There is no cash in the Trust Fund, only special interest-bearing bonds. That interest is paid with deficit spending by the government, spending facilitated by the cash received by selling those bonds to the Trust Fund!

The Social Security Trust Fund is not an asset, is is a liability that will have to be paid back.

The Nation deems it a "successful program." What? How many times has Congress had to "save" the system? How many times have we read news reports about how Social Security will run out of money in 2030, 2015, 2040, or whenever? This is success?

And couple that with the fact that "running out of money" is predicated on the assumption that there are actual assets in the Trust Fund, and we have to conclude that Social Security is bankrupt NOW.



National Committee to Preserve Social Security and Medicare
We Must Keep Social Security Out Of
Wall Street’s Hands
Recent plans discussed on Capitol Hill include privatizing Social Security. In 1935, Social Security was established as a way to create a financial safety net for retirees but these recent proposed changes could turn retirement security into a Wall Street gamble.
With private accounts tied to the Stock Market, returns would not be guaranteed, as they are now. Seniors’ savings could disappear over night and take years to rebuild after a market decline. There’s also the risk of outliving your investments—something that can never happen with Social Security.
> Act now to protect your Social Security benefits. Join us in the fight
to save your retirement income.

Turning this successful program over to the for-profit sector would cost roughly $5 trillion—a cost that would come out of taxpayers’ pockets. Unlike private investments, the cost of administering Social Security is less than 1.5% of the benefits paid. Yet there are those in Washington who want to dismantle it.
The National Committee believes that Social Security is a critical safety net meant to protect everyone and it should not become a windfall for Wall Street. Social Security is the foundation of a secure retirement. It’s designed to protect against poverty in old age and it’s one of the most successful programs in U.S. history.
Privatization is NOT a plan to save Social Security; it’s a plan to kill it. We need your support now! Add your voice to the National Committee’s by joining its efforts to protect these crucial benefits.


The National Committee to Preserve Social Security and Medicare is not affiliated with any political party or branch of government.

Monday, April 16, 2012

Revival coming

To my pastor:

As I listen to the Spirit, it seems to me that He is saying some very specific things. I write this in the hope that He is saying some of the same things to you. Of course, I may be wrong about what I discern, so please test what I have to say.
I am feeling optimistic. Expectant. I feel my faith growing. I feel like we are nearing a tipping point, or maybe a place of historical note, perhaps like when the Old Testament characters would build an altar at the place where they met God. It makes me think, maybe we are about to meet God. Perhaps He is preparing for a Visitation. Perhaps He is about to pour out His Spirit upon us.

As I’ve prayed over these last few months I am drawn to certain themes time after time. God, let Your name be glorified. God, let us take hold Your promises. God, increase our faith. Open the heavens. Fill us with Your Holy Spirit. Bring revival to this valley, to our church, to our families.

I have been reading about a little-known revival that happened in rural Arkansas in the mid 1940s. It started with only a couple of people praying and worshiping, and grew to the point where nearly every soul in the county was saved. It seems like revivals often start with just a handful of people who are willing to cry out for God’s presence.
It spurred me to begin praying for this very thing. For Him to move in our midst. Healing, salvation, anointing, power. An increase of His love in us, His compassion and mercy. That His word would be deeply rooted in us and bear fruit. These are the things that my prayers are obsessed with. 

One reason I am writing this to you now is because of an answer to prayer. I have been praying for the release of the Holy Spirit in my wife, who for many years has felt marginalized and relatively valueless in the Church. Last week I was praying for her to receive revelation about her place in the Church, for healing and health, but most of all, for her to filled with faith and confidence, that she would be able to freely worship without being preoccupied by distraction. She has the gift of discernment, but when the Spirit reveals negative spiritual forces, this tends to divert her from worshiping.

Today I saw the first fruits of an answer to that prayer. I have never seen my wife stand in front of a crowd and speak, let alone speak with such clarity and conviction. To me, this means that other prayers are going to be answered. That’s what I mean by faith growing in me. If one prayer is answered, why not two or ten or a hundred? After all, God hears from heaven. The broken and contrite spirit He will not despise.

Another reason I write is because my foolish little song was sung in church this morning. It may or may not have been successful, but for me it was significant. The last time one of my songs was sung in church was eleven years ago. God came to that church, and we witnessed a mini move of God in our midst.

Lest I start puffing myself up, I am quick to retreat from any pride. However, I must say, it’s the topic of my song that is significant to me: "Holy Spirit, You are welcome here." This song encapsulates my desire for the glorious habitation of God in our church. It is, I think, exactly what God is calling us to: Crying out for His presence.

This is the crux of my presentation: Are we ready to consider a purposeful and committed prayer for revival? Can we have a all night prayer time, once a month perhaps? Can we have extended worship times where we go in with the specific purpose to sacrificially offer up our hearts to God? Can we commit to ushering in the Presence of God by making a way for Him to come? Revival starts with prayer and a bit of faith.

I submit this to you and the rest of the leadership for prayerful consideration.


1Co. 2:4-5 My message and my preaching were not with wise and persuasive words, but with a demonstration of the Spirit’s power, so that your faith might not rest on men’s wisdom, but on God’s power.