Disclaimer: Some postings contain other author's material. All such material is used here for fair use and discussion purposes.

Monday, July 30, 2012

Fourteen defining characteristics of fascism - By Dr. Lawrence Britt

Found here. Reproduced here for fair use and discussion purposes. My comments in bold.
-------------------------------------

I note for the record that according to this author, fascists and conservatives appear to be indistinguishable. The conservative viewpoint on this would be to assign the very same tendencies to the Left, except to identify a different set of targets.

But I may as well note that fascism is an economic term. The Library of Economics and Liberty provides us with the proper definition:

"As an economic system, fascism is socialism with a capitalist veneer. The word derives from fasces, the Roman symbol of collectivism and power: a tied bundle of rods with a protruding ax. In its day (the 1920s and 1930s), fascism was seen as the happy medium between boom-and-bust-prone liberal capitalism, with its alleged class conflict, wasteful competition, and profit-oriented egoism, and revolutionary marxism, with its violent and socially divisive persecution of the bourgeoisie."
Interestingly, most of the online dictionaries deal with the totalitarian manifestations of fascism, which do not help us define the word itself. For example, Merriam Webster sort of hints at the definition, but still focuses on the manifestations:
1: a political philosophy, movement, or regime (as that of the Fascisti) that exalts nation and often race above the individual and that stands for a centralized autocratic government headed by a dictatorial leader, severe economic and social regimentation, and forcible suppression of opposition
2: a tendency toward or actual exercise of strong autocratic or dictatorial control.
And of course, there are those who throw the word around as an epithet but have no idea what it means. Ironically, they themselves often tend to display fascistic tendencies.

Dr. Britt tries to explain it to us, but only succeeds in a definition that attempts to smear his ideological opponents. Thus, he simply fashions a wordy epithet:

-------------------------------------

Dr. Lawrence Britt has examined the fascist regimes of Hitler (Germany), Mussolini (Italy), Franco (Spain), Suharto (Indonesia) and several Latin American regimes. Britt found 14 defining characteristics common to each: 

1. Powerful and Continuing Nationalism - Fascist regimes tend to make constant use of patriotic mottos, slogans, symbols, songs, and other paraphernalia. Flags are seen everywhere, as are flag symbols on clothing and in public displays.
2. Disdain for the Recognition of Human Rights - Because of fear of enemies and the need for security, the people in fascist regimes are persuaded that human rights can be ignored in certain cases because of "need." The people tend to look the other way or even approve of torture, summary executions, assassinations, long incarcerations of prisoners, etc.
3. Identification of Enemies/Scapegoats as a Unifying Cause - The people are rallied into a unifying patriotic frenzy over the need to eliminate a perceived common threat or foe: racial , ethnic or religious minorities; liberals; communists; socialists, terrorists, etc.
4. Supremacy of the Military - Even when there are widespread domestic problems, the military is given a disproportionate amount of government funding, and the domestic agenda is neglected. Soldiers and military service are glamorized.
5. Rampant Sexism - The governments of fascist nations tend to be almost exclusively male-dominated. Under fascist regimes, traditional gender roles are made more rigid. Divorce, abortion and homosexuality are suppressed and the state is represented as the ultimate guardian of the family institution.
6. Controlled Mass Media - Sometimes to media is directly controlled by the government, but in other cases, the media is indirectly controlled by government regulation, or sympathetic media spokespeople and executives. Censorship, especially in war time, is very common.
7. Obsession with National Security - Fear is used as a motivational tool by the government over the masses.
8. Religion and Government are Intertwined - Governments in fascist nations tend to use the most common religion in the nation as a tool to manipulate public opinion. Religious rhetoric and terminology is common from government leaders, even when the major tenets of the religion are diametrically opposed to the government's policies or actions.
9. Corporate Power is Protected - The industrial and business aristocracy of a fascist nation often are the ones who put the government leaders into power, creating a mutually beneficial business/government relationship and power elite.
10. Labor Power is Suppressed - Because the organizing power of labor is the only real threat to a fascist government, labor unions are either eliminated entirely, or are severely suppressed.
11. Disdain for Intellectuals and the Arts - Fascist nations tend to promote and tolerate open hostility to higher education, and academia. It is not uncommon for professors and other academics to be censored or even arrested. Free expression in the arts and letters is openly attacked.
12. Obsession with Crime and Punishment - Under fascist regimes, the police are given almost limitless power to enforce laws. The people are often willing to overlook police abuses and even forego civil liberties in the name of patriotism. There is often a national police force with virtually unlimited power in fascist nations.
13. Rampant Cronyism and Corruption - Fascist regimes almost always are governed by groups of friends and associates who appoint each other to government positions and use governmental power and authority to protect their friends from accountability. It is not uncommon in fascist regimes for national resources and even treasures to be appropriated or even outright stolen by government leaders.
14. Fraudulent Elections - Sometimes elections in fascist nations are a complete sham. Other times elections are manipulated by smear campaigns against or even assassination of opposition candidates, use of legislation to control voting numbers or political district boundaries, and manipulation of the media. Fascist nations also typically use their judiciaries to manipulate or control elections.

Wednesday, July 25, 2012

Qualifications of an Elder - Jim Elliff

Qualifications of an Elder
The following is a list of the biblical qualifications that an elder must possess. No elder will be a perfect man, but if he is clearly and persistently lacking in any of these qualities, he cannot serve in the church as an elder. An elder must be:
  1. above reproach (lit. "blameless") 1 Timothy 3:2; Titus 1:7. This qualification is the summation of all of the rest. It means that there is nothing in his life that would justify a legitimate accusation of misconduct or call his character into question.
Comment:____________________
  1. the husband of one wife (lit. "a one-woman man") 1 Timothy 3:2; Titus 1:6. Whether a man is single or married, he must be living a sexually pure life. For a married elder, it also means that he must be faithfully devoted to loving his wife (Ephesians 5:25; 1 Peter 3:7).

Comment:____________________
    temperate (moderate, not given to excess) 1 Timothy 3:2. In all areas of life, an elder must be calm, well-balanced, careful, and sane-one who at all times is capable of clear thinking and sound judgment.
    Comment:____________________
    1. sober-minded (a sensible, serious person) 1 Timothy 3:2; Titus 1:8. This does not mean that an elder may not laugh or joke or play. It means he leads a disciplined life, not allowing frivolous activities to distract him from more serious and important concerns.
    Comment:____________________
    1. of good behavior (respectable, orderly) 1 Timothy 3:2. The opposite of the Greek in this case is chaos (utter confusion). An elder's outward behavior must demonstrate decency, orderliness, and self-control.
    Comment:____________________
    1. hospitable (lit. "one who loves strangers") 1 Timothy 3:2; Titus 1:8. An elder must be one who shows genuine kindness and hospitality, not only to the members of his church, but also to people he does not know well.
    Comment:____________________
    1. a lover of what is good (lit. "one who is inclined to do good") Titus 1:8. Closely related to hospitality, an elder must be one who not only loves the concept of goodness, but also is prone to doing good to others.
    Comment:____________________
    1. able to teach (lit. "skilled in teaching") 1 Timothy 3:2; Titus 1:9. There is no biblical requirement that an elder have a formal education, but he must be an able teacher and defender of the truth (cf. 2 Timothy 2:2, 24; 2:15; Titus 2:7-8).
    Comment:____________________
    1. not given to wine (lit. "not a drinker" or "not addicted to wine") 1 Timothy 3:3; Titus 1:7. Though not an absolute prohibition, this is a serious warning that an elder cannot be preoccupied with alcohol or known as a drinker. Due to abuse, however, it may be advisable for elders to abstain from alcohol altogether in order to avoid offense or damaging influence (cf. Romans 14; 1 Corinthians 8).
    Comment:____________________
    1. not violent (lit. not "a giver of blows," or "a striker") 1Timothy 3:3; Titus 1:7. An elder must be a man who solves problems and settles disputes peacefully, using persuasive words and calm demeanor, not his fists or other weapons.
    Comment:____________________
    1. gentle (patient, gracious, forgiving) 1 Timothy 3:3; 2 Timothy 2:24. An elder must not be a man who holds a grudge or is slow to forgive. He must be one who will patiently bear with those who are needy, difficult, reluctant to change, or slow to learn.
    Comment:____________________
    1. not quick-tempered (he must be slow to anger) Titus 1:7; James 1:19-20. Anger in itself is not always a sin. There is a righteous sort of anger. An elder, though, must be a man who recognizes and controls his own propensity to become angry.
    Comment:____________________
    1. not quarrelsome (not argumentative) 1 Timothy 3:3; 2 Timothy 2:24-26; James 3:13-18. He must be a man who will defend the truth strongly, but in a peaceable manner. He must not be one who allows himself to become embroiled in hostile disputes or petty arguments.
    Comment:____________________
    1. just (righteous or upright) Titus 1:8. He is a man who is known for doing what is right. He lives a life of practical righteousness, trying to reflect God's view in every decision he makes.
    Comment:____________________
    1. holy (lit. "devout" or "set apart to God") Titus 1:8. An elder must be firmly committed to God and His Word. He must be faithful to the ministry and to biblical doctrine, not one who gives in to social, political, or religious pressure to compromise.
    Comment:____________________
    1. self-controlled (or self-disciplined) Titus 1:8. He must be a man who is disciplined in terms of his response to physical desires for food, pleasure, comfort, money, sleep, sex, or anything else which could cause him to stumble.
    Comment:____________________
    1. not covetous (not a lover of money) 1 Timothy 3:3; Titus 1:7; 1 Peter 5:2. An elder cannot be motivated in the ministry by financial gain or greedy in his lifestyle. He is a man who will trust the Lord, be content with what is provided, and be thankful.
    Comment:____________________
    1. one who rules his own house well (a good manager and leader) 1 Timothy 3:4; Titus 1:6. An elder must have proven himself a good manager of his children (if he has children), his personal finances, and his household in general.
    Comment:____________________
    1. having his children in submission with all reverence (having obedient, respectful, faithful children) 1 Timothy 3:4-5; Titus 1:6. The children of an elder must not have a reputation for uncontrolled behavior or insubordination. Additionally, an elder must not be a harsh or brutal man, but must maintain order in his family through loving leadership, consistent biblical training, and proper discipline.
    Comment:____________________
    1. not a novice (not a new or immature believer) 1 Timothy 3:6. An elder must be a mature believer, especially in relation to others in his particular church. If even a capable man is elevated to the position too rapidly, he will battle with pride.
    Comment:____________________
    1. He must have a good testimony among those who are outside (well respected even by unbelievers in the community) 1 Timothy 3:7. An elder must have a consistently good testimony in all places and with all people (aside from those who would persecute him or accuse him falsely), even outside the church. He must be just, honest, peaceable, and loving in every context.
    Comment:____________________
    1. He must serve, not by compulsion, but willingly . . . eagerly (he must desire to serve) 1 Peter 5:2; 1 Timothy 3:1. Elders must not be pressured into service if it is not their personal desire to serve in this capacity. An elder's desire to serve must be God-given and his motives pure.
    Comment:____________________
    1. not self-willed (not anxious to control others or to have his own way) Titus 1:7; 1 Peter 5:3. An elder must not be a man who is anxious to dominate or control others. He must be a team-player, realizing that while he is a shepherd, he is also one of the sheep.
    Comment:____________________
    1. an example to the flock: 1 Peter 5:3; Titus 2:7. An elder will not be perfect, but he must be a man who will lead the church, by instruction and example, according to God's Word.
    Comment:____________________
    Duties of an Elder
    In the Bible, the distinction is made between a shepherd and a hired hand (John 10:11-15). A shepherd (elder) has in his heart a God-given love for the sheep and a desire to care for those entrusted to him. The hired hand is unwilling to become as emotionally involved-unwilling to confront the dangers that threaten the sheep-unwilling to truly love the people under his care.
    As you consider a man for the position of elder, evaluate him in light of these six essential duties which characterize a good shepherd:
    1. Pastoral intimacy An elder must develop the relationships that under-gird all other ministry toward individual members. (John 10:11, 14)
    Comment:___________________________
    1. Pastoral tutelage An elder must provide personal biblical instruction for increasing character, skills, knowledge, faith, love, and enthusiasm. (Acts 20:20, 27; 1 Timothy 4:16; 2 Timothy 3:16-17; 4:1-2 Titus 3:1-2, 8)
    Comment:___________________________
    1. Pastoral guidance An elder must offer objective biblical direction through conflicts, reversals of life, distortions in thinking, and difficult decisions for those under his care. (2 Timothy 3:16-17)
    Comment:___________________________
    1. Pastoral consolation An elder must give spiritual comfort during trials. (2 Corinthians 1:3-7; Thessalonians 5:14)
    Comment:___________________________
    1. Pastoral guardianship
      An elder must watch out for the enemy's assaults on the weakness of the sheep. He must warn the sheep of danger and discipline them when they become rebellious. (Acts 20:28-31; 1 Thessalonians 5:14; 1 Timothy 6:20; 2 Timothy 4:1-5; Hebrews 13:17)
    Comment:___________________________
    1. Pastoral intercession An elder must pray with and for those entrusted to him. (1 Samuel 12:23; Romans 1:9; Ephesians 1:15-21; Philippians 1:9-11; Colossians 1:9-12)
    Comment:___________________________

    Additional Comments: _______________________
    _______________________________________
    _______________________________________
    _______________________________________

    The Little Red Hen Story

    Once upon a time, there was a little red hen who scratched about the barnyard until she uncovered some grains of wheat.
    She called her neighbors and said, "If we plant this wheat, we shall have bread to eat. Who will help me plant it?"
    "Not I," said the neighbors
    "Then I will," said the little red hen, and she did.
    The wheat grew tall and ripened into golden grain. "Who will help me reap my wheat?" asked the little red hen.
    "Not I," said the duck.
    "Out of my classification," said the pig.
    "I'd lose my seniority," said the cow.
    "I'd lose my unemployment compensation," said the goose.
    "Then I will," said the little red hen, and she did.
    At last it came time to bake the bread. "Who will help me bake the bread?" asked the little red hen.
    "That would be overtime for me," said the cow.
    "I'd lose my welfare benefits," said the duck.
    "I'm a dropout and never learned how," said the pig.
    "If I'm to be the only helper, that's discrimination," said the goose.
    "Then I will," said the little red hen.
    She baked five loaves and held them up for her neighbors to see. They wanted some and, in fact, demanded a share.
    But the little red hen said, "No, I can eat the five loaves."
    "Excess profits!" cried the cow.
    "Capitalist leech!" screamed the duck.
    "I demand equal rights!" yelled the goose.
    And the pig just grunted.
    And they painted "unfair" picket signs and marched around and around the little red hen, shouting obscenities.
    When the government agent came, he said to the little red hen, "You must not be greedy."
    "But I earned the bread," said the little red hen.
    "Exactly," said the agent. "That is the wonderful free enterprise system. Anyone in the barnyard can earn as much as he wants. But under our modern government regulations, the productive workers must divide their product with the idle."
    And they lived happily ever after, including the little red hen, who smiled and clucked, "I am grateful. I am grateful."
    But her neighbors wondered why she never again baked any more bread.

    Tuesday, July 24, 2012

    Where Have All the Children Gone in Your Church?

    Shamelessly lifted in its entirety, with all due apologies to the author.

    ----------------
    Where Have All the Children Gone in Your Church?

    July 22, 2012 By Bill Blankschaen

    “But where have all the children gone?” The classic film Chitty Chitty Bang Bang portrays the rather bizarre kingdom of Vulgaria in which children have been outlawed, banished to hide underground, separated from the world of the adults. The zany plot describes how sweet treats get offered to entice stray children into captivity.

    It’s weird. It’s a bit disturbing.



    It also describes the worship services of many evangelical churches.

    Of course, I add the usual caveat, not all of your churches do this. But a lot of them do.
    What does it look like?

    No, they don’t chase children into underground grottoes with nasty nets, but they are banished just the same. Here are a few ways it happens in evangelical churches:

    Children’s church. This approach splits off kids from parents so each can have “age appropriate” worship experiences. Often the sessions are segregated even further into elementary, middle school, and high school services. The entire approach reminds me of our popular assembly-line approach to modern education that isn’t working out so well for us anymore anyways. It’s not uncommon for sweet treats to be added to entice more kids into these services. No nets. Yet. That’s good.

    Protective policies. One mega-church I attended briefly actually included a blurb in the bulletin suggesting that we place our younger children in child care when attending the worship service. They recorded the sermons for use in a radio broadcast and didn’t want a crying child to disturb the audio quality. I think this approach well-meaning. The sermons at that church? Excellent. The radio program? High impact! But something about excluding young children from worship leaves me wondering if the end truly justified the means.

    Polite suggestions. With six children, we have often had kind parishioners — meaning no offense, mind you — notify us that separate services are available for our children. I think they assumed we obviously didn’t know about that option because our children were still with us. I love the kind gesture. It’s the subtle reasoning behind the polite suggestion that concerns me — as if everyone would be better off if children weren’t with parents in the worship service.

    I suspect the reason we — as the evangelical church — do this is to keep our kids from becoming bored during the service. We think that if they are bored, they won’t want to come to church. At least if they’re coming for the candy, they want to come. My friend John Saddington (you really should follow his blog) notes here that “bored” simply means “not fun.” So true. Rather than questioning our own assumptions, we try to convince kids that church is, in fact, always a fun and exciting place to be.

    Even if it’s not. We remake it to better suit their fun-palette at the moment.

    This urge to attract kids to church by pushing their fun-button is not new, of course. I recall similar efforts growing up in fundamentalist Protestant circles – bubble-gum-blowing contests, the world’s largest chocolate bar giveaway, and dunking the pastor in a water tank to name a few. Few of those kids who came then even claim to be Christ-followers now. Even fewer go to church.

    Jesus calls us — all of us, of all ages — to worship God in spirit and in truth, not in trendy panda or pirate curriculum with themed snacks and the world’s largest chocolate bars — as good as that might sound to some of us Ghirardelli lovers.

    Three Forgotten Things

    I suggest that when we segregate worship based on age, we forget three key things:

    1. A Promise. When Peter first preached the gospel at Pentecost, he argued that “the promise is for you and for your children….” (Acts 2:38-39 ESV) We can all disagree about the implications of that statement on the precise place of children in the visible body of Christ, but we can’t deny the tightly woven connection between preaching, parents, and their children in God’s eyes. The very first gospel appeal given after Christ’s ascension at the start of the Church culminated in a call to action for parents AND their childre

    2. A Warning. “Let the little children come to me and do not hinder them, for to such belongs the kingdom of heaven.” (Matthew 19:13-15 ESV) Jesus said that wherever two or three are gathered together in His name, he would be present in a special way. (Matthew 18:20) If worship service is the place we gather expecting to experience the presence of our Lord, don’t we come dangerously close to imitating the short-sighted disciples when we discourage children from coming to experience His presence?

    3. A Process. Scripture tells us that our children will be moved to question us as part of their learning process. When they see the things we do in worshipping God, they will ask us about it. And they will learn. “When your children say to you, ‘What do you mean by this service?’ you shall say….” (Exodus 12″21-28 ESV) If they’re not present to experience the Lord’s Supper, for example, the New Testament passover, how will they ever be moved to ask about it? How will they learn? How will they know? (You’re right. Better move on. That sounded dangerously like an ’80s Madonna song.) The church we presently attend does a fine job of encouraging this learning process, by the way, offering helpful sermon guides just for the kids. We appreciate it.

    We may not like it, but our children are the future. There’s no way around it. Assuming Christ does not return, we will die. All of us.

    What then? Will our children even know what church is as they reemerge from their segregated grotto? Or will they simply do what we’ve modeled for them and banish their own children back underground enticed by sweet treats.

    If, that is, they’re still going to church at all.

    Monday, July 23, 2012

    Opposition to ACA is immoral - Dan Lourie

    This letter appeared in today's Bozeman Chronicle. I am posting it because of its breathtaking misrepresentation of a variety of facts. I'll analyze below.

    Dan Lourie writes:

    "The Affordable Care Act (ACA) and its “mandate,” were developed by a conservative think tank and signed into law by then Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney. The mandate was the tool by which “free loaders” (Romney’s words) could no longer have their medical expenses paid by others. The Supreme Court deemed that mandate constitutional.

    "Republican candidate Romney promises to overturn the ACA, and Congressional Republicans have voted fruitlessly 33 times to annul it. All of them, it should be noted, have health insurance plans with benefits at least equal to the ACA.

    "Which of their fellow Americans do they want denied access to health care? Neighbors’ children with pre-existing conditions? Neighbors’ wives, daughters and sisters who cannot afford pre-natal and other reproductive care? The 45,000 Americans who die annually for lack of access to health care? Republican opposition to the ACA is obscene, rife with ignorance, misunderstanding, lies and an immoral disregard for the health and welfare of others. Their blind allegiance to the know-nothing tea party doctrine should embarrass thinking Republicans. Surely a plan raising the American health care system above its current abysmal world ranking of 27th should be the goal of all Americans."


    Here in one letter of less than 300 words is the complete arsenal of leftist talking points. let's take them one by one.

    "The Affordable Care Act (ACA) and its “mandate,” were developed by a conservative think tank..." This is the transcription of a lecture delivered by Stuart M. Butler of the Heritage Foundation in 1989, entitled "Assuring Affordable Healthcare for All Americans." At the bottom of the second page is this phrase: "Nothing written here is to be construed as necessarily reflecting the views of The Heritage Foundation..."

    As one reads the transcription, it becomes apparent that this man is not proposing anything like the ACA. But rather than discuss its details, I'll let you follow the link and read it yourself. Inconveniently, Dr. Butler wrote a refutation of those who mischaracterize his lecture from 1989. He specifically refutes the idea that "a conservative think tank" developed the ACA. Indeed, he takes to task those who would take a small phrase from his lecture and make it the major theme.

    I will say, though, that just because a "conservative" proposes something doesn't make it conservative. And one "conservative" does not make a movement. Also, proposing a mandate is not the same thing as proposing government controlled healthcare. Regardless, the essay, attributable to a "conservative, is prima facia evidence that unlike the political left, we conservatives welcome the exchange of ideas.

    Further, the mere fact that the Left is bringing up supposed conservative support for government healthcare is a tacit admission that it is not a conservative position. THEY know the difference! But I wonder, who is fooled by this kind of rhetoric? Oh, yeah. Mr. Laurie. Doubtless he read something on a leftist website and simply regurgitated it in his letter.

    "...and signed into law by then Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney." What might this be about? The ACA is federal legislation passed by congress and signed by President Obama, not Governor Romney. And Romney is hardly conservative, so citing his prior support for government healthcare lends no weight to the argument. Regardless, Romney has made clear that he believes that states can do things that the feds cannot. Mr. Lourie is obviously mixing concepts. His muddled prose definitely detracts from his position.

    "The Supreme Court deemed that mandate constitutional." And the Supreme Court said that blacks were property in Dred Scott. Next question.

    "...Congressional Republicans have voted fruitlessly 33 times to annul it..." No, the house has voted twice to repeal it, and is passed both times, with the help of some democrats who also voted for repeal.

    "Which of their fellow Americans do they want denied access to health care?" This is a pet peeve of mine. Apparently, if one opposes the government "solution" to a problem, then one must somehow be in favor of the problem. This is vapid and anti-intellectual. No one with an IQ above room temperature believes that being in opposition to bad legislation means that they are in favor of the problem.

    Say, let's see how he likes his own medicine. Might we also ask Mr. Lourie why he is in favor of 10 million Americans being without healthcare under ACA? The ACA is not univeral healthcare. Is Mr. Laurie in favor of letting people die? Hmm?

    "Republican opposition to the ACA is obscene, rife with ignorance, misunderstanding, lies and an immoral disregard for the health and welfare of others." With breathless hyperbole Mr. Lourie characterizes his ideological opponents as monsters and ax murderers. But I don't know why I'm typing these refutations. All I have to do is call Mr. Lourie names. I can make all sorts of claims with the same fidelity for the truth that Mr. Lourie embraces, and like him, neither advance the debate nor engage the ideas.

    And this pontification about morality mystifies me. Whose morality is he talking about? Who is he to pass moral judgments about other people? This black-and-white morality needs to be abandoned in favor of more nuanced understanding. He needs to stop imposing his morality on others and stop the hate.

    "Surely a plan raising the American health care system above its current abysmal world ranking of 27th should be the goal of all Americans." He can't know that ACA will raise our ranking. He doesn't even know if healthcare will improve, or cost less, or be more efficient. Just because his side has said so does not make it so. Nor is he in a position to dictate what the goal of all Americans should be. There are lots of reasons our health system is ranked poorly, not the least of which is the fact that government has so totally messed it up. What ACA is really about is offering a government fix to the government fixes previously installed.

    Mr. Lourie, like all true believers, lives in a world of stark contrasts. If you oppose what he favors, you are not simply wrong, you are evil. If you are not for him, you are against him. He believes that government is the answer to all life's problems, government is where we should look every time we need something or perceive some injustice. It would never occur a person like Mr. Lourie that there are a variety of solutions to the problems of society, solutions that are often quite different than his. But he wants none of it, because he is not only convinced he is right, but that there is no other way to look at things.

    A friend recently posted this quote from William F. Buckley, and it's very perceptive: "Liberals claim to want to give a hearing to other views, but then are shocked and offended to discover that there are other views."

    Friday, July 20, 2012

    The Incestuous Sale of the Story Mansion - Editorial

    The Chronicle recently reported that a breath-taking $47,000 was spent for landscaping the Story mansion, of which $17,000 was paid by the City as part of the buy-sell agreement.

    Why would the City agree to pay part of the landscaping in a deal where we are already losing millions? What kind of business acumen does it take to sell a property at a gargantuan loss and commit to an additional $17,000 for flowers? This is your tax dollars they are wasting.

    Let me walk you through the tangled web. The city purchased the property for $1.3 million from a fraternity in 2003. In total, roughly $3.3 million in federal, state, and local taxpayer funds were spent. Oh, and let’s not forget the lost property tax revenues from it being off the taxpayer rolls.

    You might recall a group called Friends of the Story Mansion had an odd arrangement with the City to come up with $391,222 within 2 years to pay back the City. The City obtained this money from property tax revenues so that it could secure a $500,000 federal grant in a deal known as the "Becker Amendment," named after Commissioner Sean Becker. Well, we know the Friends failed, and per the agreement the mansion was put up for sale.

    And sell it did, to a non-profit organization called Exergy Friends of the Story Mansion, or EFSM. EFSM is a non-profit formed by the partnership of Exergy Integrated Systems (EIS) and, surprise, Friends of the Story Mansion. Oh, and former City of Bozeman planning director Andy Epple, director of the Friends, is also the director of EFSM.

    According to an April 14, 2011 Chronicle article, EIS sent a letter to the Bozeman City commission on April 1, 2011 suggesting that be allowed to purchase the property for, surprise, $391,222. The writer of the letter was former MSU professor Gordon Brittan, who is now EIS’s director of new product development, and not coincidentally, also the vice president of EFSM.

    The article seems to indicate that the letter was sent by EIS and not the non-profit shell called EFSM (I call it a shell because according to www.taxexemptworld.com, EFSM has no assets or income). But a change in strategy must have occurred somewhere along the line, because a later Chronicle article (July 27, 2011) informs us that “under the proposal, Exergy would partner with Friends of the Story Mansion to form a joint nonprofit….”

    Note the future tense, “…would partner….” As we know, the City is forbidden from selling the property for less than 90% of its appraised value, unless the sale is to a non-profit. So the yet-to-be-formed non-profit EFSM was apparently conceived expressly to facilitate the below-market purchase of the Story Mansion, in a deal with many of the same players that were part of the failed “Friends” deal.

    One might conclude that Friends of Story Mansion had found their bankroll in EIS and established EFSM to funnel the purchase price through a non-profit. As a result, the Friends can continue to control the object of its affection without having to come up with a dime of its own money.

    I’d be the first to assume the best, but given the track history of the City and the previous failure of the Friends, a bit of skepticism is justified. This is the same City that messed up the transfer station, demanded Facebook passwords of its employees, paid fines to former employees, created a lightly used bus system and parking garage, and charged Wal-Mart $500,000 in extortion money

    Story Mansion is a loser, made worse by a buy-sell agreement in which the taxpayers lose even more. Even worse, these same commissioners are piling on, now claiming to know that the new McDonald’s building design “…effectively turns the entire building into a sign and creates an unfair advantage for the business…” Um, yeah. They know all about unequal business deals, don’t they?

    Thursday, July 19, 2012

    We don't need someone to think; Grover Norquist - FB conversation

    My FB friend S.B. shared this

    all things considered, I like the OTHER Grover better.



    Elect Mitt Romney and you make Grover Norquist's ultimate wet dream come true.

    J.P.:Grover Nordquist is an anarchist and a humbug.

    J.P.: Or douchbag if you prefer

    J.M.: Grover Cleavland was a Congressman (the only sitting member of the US House to be elected President) President, AND then later Cheif Justice of the Suppreme Court. But the thing that most history books mention is that he was a big guy and wanted a man's size bathtub installed in the whitehouse. Presidents with facial hair were a manly lot.

    J.S.: I finally understand why Romney got the nomination over Paul. He does look good holding a pen.

    Me: I don't particularly like Norquist. But if you actually listen to his speech, his point is that with a conservative congress a conservative president isn't crucial. He asserts that Obama is nothing more than a pen wielder himself. His speech is 23 minutes, which is probably 22:30 more than most liberals have actually heard from him: http://www.blogforiowa.com/2012/02/22/grover-norquist-at-cpac-republicans-dont-need-someone-who-can-think/

    R.S.: It's hard to believe that only a dozen or so years ago, the federal government had a budget surplus. What on earth happened?

    J.P.: Two wars and a medicare expansion simultaneous with a massive regressive tax cut and very bad finance deregulation -- all promoted by the GOP. Hey let's put them back in the White House!

    Me: Never was a clinton surplus, sorry...

    J.P.: Actually, based on multiple data sources including the US Treasury, there was a Federal budget surplus that began in 1997 and ended just prior to 2002. It peaked at 2.3% of GDP in 2000 just as GW Bush (R) came into office -- GW Bush gets credit for a year of surplus :) -- 9/11 hadn't happened yet. Those who say there was no Clinton (D) surplus either claim that the GOP majority in Congress was responsible or they exclude payroll tax from Federal revenue. Since WWII, Truman (D) ran the largest (4.3% of GDP at it's peak) and most sustained surpluses (5 of 8 years: there was an astonishing amount of red ink in WWII), Eisenhower (R) was a mixed bag but ran a significant surplus (more than 1%) for about 3 years of 8, LBJ (D) ran a snipet of a surplus for a single year. Clinton (3 years of 8) and Bush (1 year of 8) were the last POTUS's to run a Federal surplus. That recent surplus was only surpassed by Truman. Prior to the Great Depression, it was common to run a small surplus or deficit of 1% to 2% in a fluctuating manner. The only large deficit excursions were major wars (Civil, WWI, WWII largest by far, Iraq/Afghanistan). The largest recent deficit occured right at the beginning of 2009 (right as Obama came into office because of two wars and a collapse of GDP and tax revenue with it) it was 10% and is expected to shrink to about 5% by 2014 based on nonpartisan CBO projections. Reagan's (R) peacetime deficits exceeded that of the Vietnam war period rising as high as 6% in his 3rd year in office. Reagan and GHW Bush (R) stabilized the deficit below 5% till Clinton, partially by raising taxes (which was the political end of GHWB because of the namesake of this thread). Clinton drove the deficit down in a linear path from 1993 to 2000 from 4% deficit to 2.3% surplus. I argue the linear reduction negates the common GOP argument that the GOP Congress made Clinton reduce the deficit. Clinton reduced the deficit by roughly and equal amount every year he was in office.

    J.P.: Another curious thing is that Clinton raised taxes significantly over the tax increases of GHW Bush. This allowed the large and consistent deficit reductions and at the same time the US economy grew like gang busters. I made a ton of money and kept most of it despite the dot bomb implosion at the end of the Clinton Administration. I paid lots of taxes but my personal wealth far outran anything since GW Bush came to the White House. The market has been doo doo ever since. My anecdotal experience is that economic growth and real wealth in the upper middle class brackets are not that sensitive to marginal tax rates (most of us don't exclusively pay the top income, dividend and capital gains rates). What is sensitive to marginal rates is the deficit. Higher rates, less deficit spending. What caused the economic collapse was poor deregulation of the finance industry. In fact, it was a total disaster. It's not directly linked to the deficit at this point. That could change if we emerge from this deflationary period and don't tame the red ink. I argue by raising $2 trillion in taxes to pay for two wars that we charged on credit. It's irresponsible to charge wars on a credit card, no? T-bill rates might rise and that will cause a significant problem. Defaulting on the debt would have forced the linkage immediately and could have collapsed the economy into full blown depression as T-bill rates could have gone to junk bond status, preventing the government from floating the economy in the midst of economic crisis.

    Me: Sorry, J.P., you are wrong, despite your many words to the contrary: http://www.treasurydirect.gov/govt/reports/pd/histdebt/histdebt_histo4.htm

    J.P.: Annual changes in the government net worth is more complicated than looking up the number of total government instruments in circulation. Gee, that's even true for little old me. Even you prefer that simplistic accounting, far fewer additional government instruments went into circulation under Clinton than any since Truman. So much for Reagan and the new Republicans.

    J.P.: My point is, the Democrats have a slightly better record of keeping the books than the Republicans. It's hard to keep one's finances together when you quit all your revenue streams. No surprises there.

    Me: So you admit there was no surplus? Good.

    I really don't care who has the not-quite-as-bad record on finances. Both parties have violated the public trust, both parties have wasted trillions of dollars, both parties are guilty of the worst kind of deliberate malfeasance.

    Revenue, by the way, has not been the problem. Spending has.

    J.P.: I admit no such thing. We are talking about two different things. You're talking about the total number of federal instruments in play in a given year (they are listed in your table). I'm talking about the deficits and surpluses on the federal budget. They are not the same thing nor have they been -- ever. The Treasury is responsible for things beyond the federal budget. For example, some "minor issues" such as the US currency and, in cooperation with the Fed, control of the money supply through the reserve banking system. The Treasury can retire debt instruments through buy backs using either surplus cash or with new debt instruments (generally at lower interest rates). Such things are not part of the federal goverment operating budget (descretionary plus entitlements, etc.). Moreover, there are smoke and mirror categories that are "off-budget" that have been used both legitimately and when politically convienient (Bush ran many of his war approps through those mechanisms rather than increase taxes I seem to recall). Personally, I think the budgeting system could be reformed to make it honest, but it is what it is and I'm not in charge of that. In terms of the official definitions, Clinton ran a federal budget surplus and so did GWB and the others I mentioned. In the universe I live in, economies have two uber dimensions: supply and demand. Finance has two uber dimensions: revenue and spending. I don't live in a one dimensional world dominated only by expenses. In my read of the history of empire and technology, no great thing has been done to change the world for the better by penny pinchers. Big things are done by nations that tax and spend. What's killing us is borrow and spend -- a Reagan doctrine that has taken over our entire system. Antigens, like Grover Nordquist are backstopping that process of national destruction. If we don't quit doing that, Grover's dream will come true: 1) the US will go bankrupt, or 2) the US will contract into an unimportant former world power. Taxes will not be the end of us, but mass stupidity could be.

    Me: You can blow all the smoke you want, and you can pretend how sophisticated the issue is, but it is simple: If the amount of debt increases in subsequent years, there is no surplus. I really don't care how you frame it. I don't care who you blame or give credit to. I don't care if you think it's a good thing to spend oodles of money. None of that matters. The national debt has increased every year for decades.

    Wednesday, July 11, 2012

    Bad worship song lyrics - Running, by Scott Ligertwood and Matt Crocker

    From time to to we examine the lyrics of worship songs. Our desire is not to mock or humiliate, but rather to honestly examine content with a view to calling forth a better worship expression.

    With the great volume and variety of worship music available, none of us should have to settle for bad worship songs. We should be able to select hundreds or even thousands of top notch songs very easily.

    What makes a song a worship song? Is it enough to contain words like God or holy? How about vaguely spiritual sounding phrases? Should Jesus be mentioned? 

    We think an excellent worship song should contain the following elements:
    • A direct expression of adoration (God, you are...)
    • A progression of ideas that culminates in a coherent story
    • A focus on God, not us
    • Lyrics that do not create uncertainty or cause confusion
    • A certain amount of profundity
    • A singable, interesting melody
    • Allusions to Scripture
    • Doctrinal soundness
    • Not excessively metaphorical
    • Not excessively repetitive
    • Jesus is not your boyfriend
    It's worth noting the most worship songs contain at least something good. That is, there might be a musical idea or a lyric that has merit. Such is the case with this song.

    This song is found on worshiptogether.com, which usually has very high quality worship songs. A discussion follows.

    Verse 1
    Ready at the line looking out, looking out to all that's ahead
    When every heart confesses Your Name, we're pressing on towards that day
    We're never gonna stop, we're never gonna stop

    Verse 2
    Letting go of every mistake, throwing off the chains of restraint
    All that will remain a passion for Your Name, burning as we run this race
    We're never gonna stop, we're never gonna stop

    Chorus
    We are running, chasing after all that You are
    We are running, 'cause all that You are is all that we want

    Verse 3
    Every stride is taken in faith, every step compelled by Your grace
    We're taking up our cross, no matter what the cost
    We give it all to go Your way,
    We're never gonna stop, we're never gonna stop

    Interlude
    Woah, woah, woah

    Bridge
    Onwards we draw towards Your light
    Desperate we seek to know You more and more
    Further we look beyond ourselves
    To Your love, to Your love

    -------------------------------

    Monday, July 9, 2012

    Jack Kligerman, local letter writer, and Steve Daines

    Mr. Kligerman writes to the Bozeman Chronicle, followed by my analysis:

    "Polonius meets Hamlet and asks him, 'What do you read, my Lord?' Hamlet answers, 'Words, words, words.' When pressed for their meaning, Hamlet continues, 'Slanders, sir.'

    "Now the very many large signs that support Steve Daines — which bear the slogan, 'More Jobs; Less Government' — may not be slanderous, yet what they imply along with words of the Super Pacs directed against Obama, Tester and, soon, I am sure, Kim Gillan, come as close to slander as possible. But surely Daines’s words are empty, since there is no necessary correlation between smaller government at every level and more jobs. In fact, states that have the highest unemployment rates have reduced their number of government employees (e.g. teachers, police, fire personnel). Hence, in spite of a steady growth in private sector jobs over the past three years, unemployment remains high.

    "As for less government, what would Daines sacrifice? Highways? Air controllers? The military? The Center for Disease Control? National parks? Services for the poor, elderly, women and children? Etc. Etc. When one looks closely, the slogan, 'More Jobs; Less Government' means nothing."

    Jack Kligerman

    Bozeman

    ------------

    Slander: a malicious, false, and defamatory statement or report.

    Mr. Kligerman, with no hint that he gets his own irony, slanders candidate Steve Daines with vague suggestions of impropriety, apparently unhindered by his failure to provide a single bit of evidence backing up his claim. But this is typical behavior for the Left.

    One might justifiably wonder how a statement like "more jobs, less government" can in any way be slanderous, and against whom. Did Mr. Daines slander Obama, Tester, or Kim Gillian in some fashion, or was it the unnamed super pacs who did so? Or was Mr. Kligerman prognosticating that Mr. Daines is soon to engage in slander? Really, what is Mr. Kligerman actually trying to say?

    He writes, "Daines’s words are empty, since there is no necessary correlation between smaller government at every level and more jobs." Note the two added qualifiers, "necessary" and "at every level." Mr. Daines has made no claim that there is a "necessary" correlation that less government means more jobs "at every level." But again, this is typical behavior from the Left, introducing words into simple statements in order to twist the meaning or context of the statement.

    Indeed, the statement "More jobs, less government" isn't actually requiring that the two phrases are correlated. Mr. Daines obviously supports two positions. He wants more jobs, and he wants less government. Linking them is not necessary, especially considering we are talking about a campaign sign. A slogan on a campaign sign is not the same thing as communicating nuanced, in depth policy theses. Nevertheless, I suspect that this single phrase is as much research as Mr. Kligerman has done regarding Mr. Daines's campaign positions.

    Mr. Kligerman continues: "In fact, states that have the highest unemployment rates have reduced their number of government employees (e.g. teachers, police, fire personnel)." Unlike Mr. Kligerman, I shall cite my references. According to government unemployment statistics, the ten highest states for unemployment are nearly all governed by Democrats, and are characterized by big government, deficit spending, and financial mismanagement. Clearly there are other factors at work besides Mr. Kligerman's pedantic assertion, which suggests that Mr. Kligerman is engaging in lazy thinking, incomplete research, or he's just repeating talking points.

    He continues: "Hence, in spite of a steady growth in private sector jobs over the past three years, unemployment remains high." Hmm. It appears that Mr. Kligerman is suggesting that persisting high unemployment is because government hasn't hired/retained enough people. You know, it's not hard to investigate these facts. First, private sector employment figures from the government's own website:



    You'll note that private sector employment has increased by only 160,000 jobs from January 2009 to now. So the first thing we need to note is that there has been little growth, steady or otherwise, in the private sector, let alone the 2.6 million jobs trumpeted by Obama apologists.

    Here's public sector employment since 1984:



    As you can see, there was a general downward trend in federal employment during the Bush II years, which was violently reversed starting in 2008. While 2011 figures are not available, there is no reason to expect that the expansion of government has abated. Suffice to say, the numbers are not in favor of Mr. Kligerman.

    Moving on. Mr. Kligerman superciliously writes, "As for less government, what would Daines sacrifice? Highways? Air controllers? The military? The Center for Disease Control? National parks? Services for the poor, elderly, women and children? " You will note another typical tactic of the Left, that is, equating cuts in government with a narrowly selected list of government activities that the average person would be adverse to cutting. Might one justifiably ask, are there are no other things in $3.83 trillion of federal spending that can be cut?

    I have come to the conclusion that the Left is simply interested in promulgating talking points, assuming that the emotional content of them is sufficient to sway opinions. Whether or not they are true is less important than if they work. As such, it appears that leftists Like Mr. Kligerman are deliberately misrepresenting the truth in order to further an agenda. This is not surprising, but it is nonetheless distressing and needs to be continually pointed out.

    Friday, July 6, 2012

    Why I Support Obama - I voted for him before and will vote for him again.

    This is on Obama's campaign website, and is also appearing in places like Facebook.



    I transcribed it and interlaced my commentary in bold:

    1) For 30 years I’ve heard politicians talking about health care reform, and he’s the first one to do something about it.

    Actually, all sorts of programs have been installed over the decades, the most notable of which include Medicare, Medicaid, Prescription Drugs, and HMO legislation. Interestingly, this last item was instituted by none other than democrat Ted Kennedy. So it is simply false to assert that Obama is the first to do something.

    The Affordable Care Act removes restrictions on pre-existing conditions, makes healthcare affordable for small businesses, raises the age at which children can be on their parents’ policies, removes lifetime caps, and more.

    These are the benefits given incessant fanfare, but what about the remaining 1699 pages of the legislation? Do you think there is the possibility that there might be something important contained there? Like more than 100 new bureaucracies? Pages and pages of review boards, regulations, requirements, and penalties?

    And, since these trumpeted features are expansions of coverage, one might justifiably conclude that these have to cost someone something somewhere.


    With the possible exception of insurance execs, who would not want these changes?

    Actually, the insurance industry stands to make a boatload of money from obamacare. After all, the number of uninsured people is supposed to decrease, which means millions more customers.

    The 60+ percent of people who don't like obamacare are not ignorant of its features, which is how its supporters like to dismiss them. The fact is, most people don't like to be told what they need, they know from experience that the government frequently makes things worse, and they also realize that what they are told will happen does not happen with surprising frequency.


    2) He ended the war in Iraq and is drawing the war in Afghanistan to a close. Like he said he would.

    Generally speaking, President Obama simply followed the timeline put in place by Bush. Almost without exception, Obama continued Bush's agenda. Like keeping Gitmo open. Like killing terrorists like Osama. And ironically, this is all courtesy of the Nobel Peace Prize-winning president.

    3) He thinks women should have access to free preventative health care. Why is this still an issue?

    Why does anyone (let alone women) feel like they're entitled to free anything? And has anyone stopped to figure out who is paying for this free stuff? And why is it only women who are entitled to free preventative health care? And why is it self-evident that this shouldn't be an issue?

    4) He believes in equality for all people and signed the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act to help women get equal pay for equal work... Even the Left-leaning Slate knows that this is largely a fiction, perpetrated by people who are unable to engage in appropriate statistical analysis but instead rely on broad generalizations.

    One might wonder if there is any outrage for the fact that top Democrats in Congress routinely pay their female staffers less than male staffers. Including Obama. Female employees in the Obama White House make considerably less than their male colleagues, records show.

    According to the 2011 annual report on White House staff, female employees earned a median annual salary of $60,000, which was about 18 percent less than the median salary for male employees ($71,000).


    ...and the repeal of the military’s “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” policy. Which was installed by President Bill Clinton...

    5) He is promoting and investing in clean energy jobs. Finally. Really? How much stock in green energy does President Obama own in his investment portfolio? Oh, sorry, you meant he's investing OUR money in clean energy.

    And what a great investment! Green energy companies are going bankrupt left and right, sometimes right after accepting government money.


    6) He supports education by giving more flexibility to No Child Left Behind (thank you!) and by making college aid more available.

    NCLB is legislation. Does President Obama now have the power to pass, rescind, or modify legislation? When was the Constitution amended to allow the President to do such things? We know he is ignoring other pieces of legislation, like refusing to enforce the Defense of Marriage act. Whatever you might think of the duly passed laws of the land, you must agree that the law must be obeyed and enforced.

    7) He thinks millionaires and billionaires should pay their fair share of taxes like the rest of us. Really, this is a no brainer.

    I suspect that the phrase "no brainer" is an appropriate selection of language. The IRS keeps track of who pays taxes, which is unfortunate for those who believe that the rich don't pay their fair share.



    8) Despite inheriting one of the worst economic messes since the Great Depression, he added 2.6 million private sector jobs to our economy, and indications are that the economy is slowly improving. To anyone who thinks he’s been too slow – don’t you know you can’t turn the Titanic around in a day? 
    Obama's hand has been at the helm of the Titanic as both Senator and President since 2007. He has been in ideological agreement with those who brought on this disaster for much longer. As a senator, Obama participated in the budgets, voted in favor of the bailouts, and was involved in all the financial dealings and initiatives that came before the Senate. He had a democratic congress his first two years as president, and did nothing. So, he didn't inherit anything, he created it, voted for it, and agreed with it and continued it.

    He didn't add any jobs to the economy. Employers did. And the number 2.6 million is only one half of the equation. The other half is how many jobs have been lost. In 2009, 142,187,000 people were working. This year: 142,287,000 people are. That's an increase of 100,000 jobs since the official end of the recession. 2.6 million jobs may have been created, but almost as many have been destroyed.

    Regarding the slow nature of changing course, the average duration of recessions/depressions is 18 months. The notable exceptions are the Great Depression and now the 2008 recession, both of which are characterized by huge government interventions and myriad spending programs. Is it possible that the intractable nature of this recession is being made worse by Obama?


    I voted for him before and will vote for him again. 


    Good luck with that.

    Tuesday, July 3, 2012

    Linda McCulloch and the Fourth of July email



    I just received this from the Montana Secretary of State. Analysis below.





    There is so much wrong with this relatively short statement. Maybe I'm nit-picking, but stuff like this bothers me. So where do I start?

    1) "The 4th of July celebrates our democracy..." No it doesn't, because there was no government at all besides the British Crown. And even when the government was finally formed, we were given not a democracy but a representative republic.

    2) "It serves as a reminder that we, as American citizens, share the right and the responsibility to elect the people who make and uphold our laws." No, it serves as a reminder that government tends to suppress and oppress, and therefore the people have the right to throw off this oppression.

    I wonder if Ms. McCulloch realizes that there is no enumerated right to vote mentioned in the Constitution until the 14th amendment was passed on July 9, 1868. One might justifiably wonder if there was no right to vote, as liberals conventionally construe the meaning of rights, until nearly 100 years after the Declaration? And where did this idea of the responsibility to vote come from?

    3) "I encourage you to celebrate your right to vote..." This is so strange that it barely needs commenting on, except to say that the idea of celebrating a right must be akin to celebrating a birthday, apparently.

    Monday, July 2, 2012

    Christians should support Obamacare - FB conversation

    LCB, a FB friend, shared this:

    Aint it the truth



    MS: Trump is a moron, and I think he was born in Kenya.

    JS: fascist extortion, thats about the size of it. Bro Copeland did an excellent expose teaching on socialism, spoke powerfully to me, an Englishman (not a european...). Basically any form of social economic or political organisation that is outside of the body of Christ and the governance of God Almighty and His written word is babelish, socialistic and anti Christian, wether its blackshirt german national socialists, red soviet marxists, popish romanism etc etc and no matter how noble, just or moral it MAY appear to be. LOL I love one of Ken's comments "the devil will pay you NOT to work..."

    MS: Yeah, they say the devil will find work for idol hands... But seriously, doesn't the bible command to care for the poor and sick? I don't think you're going to find Mr. Trump in heaven. If there indeed IS a heaven.

    Me: Does the Bible command government take money from one person, by force if necessary, and give it to another?

    MS: Rich, do you mean to say that the Affordable Healthcare Act would be the first and only time the government has intended to take money from one person and give it to another? Did the Bible command the government to take my money and spend it on a war in Iraq? Or give subsidies to oil companies? Pay for Medicaid/Medicare? Build a road in some other part of the country? ALL taxes effectively take money away from one person and give it to someone else.

    LS: The Bible says give unto the government that which is the government, And of course the government determines what that is. Just the same the Affordable Healthcare act really isn't affordable, especially now. We were told that there would be no new tax and low and behold,new taxes on the middle class. For that matter had not the Chief Justus rewritten the act to read taxes it would not have been viewed constitutional. So the way I look at it this was not a win for Obama. The tax act will be rewritten when Romney takes office.

    MS: How many "middle class" people do you know who have no form of health coverage? No VA, no Medicare/Medicaid, no employer insurance? Because if they have any of those, they will not have to pay this "tax." You certainly won't have to pay it, Mom. Also, members of Native American tribes won't have to pay. People who make too little to file taxes won't have to pay. If insurance would cost more that 8% of your income you will not have to pay. If you are part of a religion opposed to acceptance of benefits from a health insurance you will not have to pay. All of those things and more will keep you from having to pay this tax. However, if you COULD afford insurance but chose not to, there's a good chance you will have to pay this tax. Why, because when you go to the emergency room you get a FREE RIDE... which the rest of us have been paying for decades. The larger point however, is not penalize people but to provide them with affordable healthcare. If you make less than 400% of the federal poverty level, you will get federal help paying for it.
    It will be a sad day if Romney gets a chance to repeal this law - because it is almost exactly the same plan he put in place in Massachusetts. His success with Romney care is the one achievement that put him on a path to the white house. Love you. :)

    LJB: Very good Marshal and thank you for the information. It's very helpful!

    LCB: What most people have missed is that Chief Justice Roberts was put in place by the Bilderbergers AKA New World Order. The bothced swearing in of Obama was no mistake but a carefully calculated move so that the oath he took in secret, never to be revealed, was an oath to the NWO

    LS: Son, what your failing to recognize is that Indian health is a joke, and the VA health and Medicade and Medicare are very poorly run. How about they getting it right before they take on more. Practice doesn't make perfect, perfect practice makes perfect. You know I have had to fight tooth and toenail for every benefit dad has. Someone has to pay for this, there isn't money for it, where is the money coming from? The truly poor have more help available than most of us, there are always exceptions, of course. Pharmaceutical companies help, there are free clinics springing up all over and you can not be denied health care if you go to an emergency room. We don't have any of the above because we are on Medicare. Do I think the poor should be helped, yes, the truly poor who can not help themselves. Unfortunately to many are "poor" simply because they know how to work the system. We all know people who just don't want to work and earn their own way. It's obvious that something needs to be done, but this was passed without anyone really know even whats in the bill. Know anyone who has read the whole thing? They certainly hadn't before it was passed. Love you too son.

    Me: MS, I don't think I suggested this was the first time government has forced people to give their wealth to others. It's still just as wrong this time as it was the last 20 times, whether it be the war in Iraq or subsidies to oil companies. Or are you saying that because it happened before it's perfectly fine now?

    An no, not ALL taxes are taking from one and giving to another. A road is not a wealth transfer. A powerplant is not the result of ataking money from one and giving to another using the coercive power of government. A military is not formed by forcing someone to pay for it by giving money to another.

    I would think the difference is pretty clear.

    MS: I don't always drink beer, but when I do, I prefer Dos Equis.

    I'm saying that the taxes we pay inevitably wind up in someone else's pocket. Do you consider using tax money to give someone preventive medical care to be a transfer of wealth? It doesn't put cash into the recipient's pocket... it pays the doctor and the hospital, sure. By the same token, building a road puts tax money into the pockets of construction workers. How is that not a transfer of wealth?

    Tell me how exactly the penalty on your tax return for not taking the personal responsibility for your healthcare is more coercive than any other tax penalty. That's what I'm getting at.

    JS: These schemes are always about hiring and maintaining a client group entourage of state-loyal people. If you think this is about wealth redistribution for the sake of social justice, think again. Its about establishing health industry jobs and pensions for (what we call in the UK) "jobsworths" (sorry cant do that its more than my job's worth) They undermine the activity of a free market enterprise system by draining more and yet more tax money, and interfering in free enterprise by enforcing of petty, yet nevertheless draconian, regulations and punitive expenses, fees, costs (ie stealth taxations). LOL believe it or not at one stage well over 50% of working people in the (devoutly and piously socialist North East of England) were employed by the state in one form or another. So called public sector services....LOL The ONE thing these folks ARE very good at is making dead certain they get their dues paid to them on time, every time....Like I said fascist extortion. Its a fact theres no peace without the Prince of Peace (ie Yeshua, Lord Jesus Christ)

    Me: MS, I prefer Fat Tire or Moose Drool, But if you put a rum and Coke in front of me...

    Three things. First, responsibility for my healthcare rests with me and not government, not you, and not some family in Florida. 2) If government somehow has a right to legislate regarding my health choices, that means it can force me to eat less fat, exercise more, and give up cigars. There is no remedy available, for government then can make any intrusion in the name of "health." 3) There is no constitutional authority for government to select who gets money from whom and how it is distributed in society.

    The distinction (I risk repeating myself), is that there are specific beneficiaries, chosen by government, and specific payors, also chosen by government, and as a result a direct transfer of wealth happens. This is immoral. However, anyone can drive on a road no matter how rich, anyone can flush their toilet and their crap runs just as willingly to the processing center. These are not transfers of wealth (um, not talking about the crap...).

    Friday, June 29, 2012

    The individual mandate - FB conversation

    R.W. posted this:

    Obamacare simplified.



    YUP...This about covers it nicely! If you agree LIKE this and SHARE this with your friends!

    B.R.: Yes, you're correct, that logic is dumb.

    R.W.: That is what was just declared constitutional.

    B.R.: you're intentionally eschewing the importance of this system. Gum is a ridiculous thing to compare to health care.

    K.B.: Reductio ad absurdum. It works with people who DIDN'T study debate in Junior High School.

    Poor argument. Entertaining reading.

    Me: How about this: We have a huge unsold inventory of single family homes. This clearly has a substantial potential impact on the country's well-being. Why not force renters to purchase a home or pay a penalty (um, tax)?

    R.W.: Your point is a red herring Ben. It doesn't matter how important it is. The no gum tax is legal. According to 5 idiots on the the court you can be taxed on a non-action. It is only up to the whim of the majority to determine what they f...eel is important. When the right wing gets in power, they may decide that you have the right not to attend church. But if you don't participate you will be taxed. Want to buy a prius? Fine but you have to pay the NOT BUYING AMERICAN tax. Don't have solar panels? That is your right. Just pay the Raping of Mother Earth tax.

    R.W.: K.B., maybe I didn't finish Junior High so I'm not as learned as you, but if you cant see the correlation, maybe its not my intelligence that should be called into question. It's not that hard. Don't purchase a commercial product from a private company and pay a tax. It doesn't matter what the product is!

    B.R.: ‎90% of Americans are going to NEED a certain industry in the next 5 years, and it's not gum or single family homes or church or a prius or solar panels. My costs for those innocuously compared items don't skyrocket when the rest of America...ns decide to stay opted out. You're taking an enormously important and complex program and boiling it down to one personal value that you disagree with. Next time a Republican wins the White House and he or she starts to change things in big ways, I'm going to try and understand the whole story, not just the elements that go against my personal convictions.

    K.B.: Come, come, R.W ... you didn't publish that cartoon to make a compelling legal point. You posted that cartoon because it was funny. And it is!! It made ME laugh!

    And I see the correlation. Of course I do. That's why the cartoon is fu...nny. But it is Reductio ad absurdum. It is entertainment. It is not a compelling legal argument. If it were, cartoons and bumper stickers would be submitted to the Supreme Court instead of thousands and thousands of pages of briefs.

    B.R.: I like your point, Kevin - liberals are equally guilty of promoting these kinds of things, maybe even more so since they're reliably funnier.

    K.B.: Oh, HELL YES!! Liberals are just as guilty of it as anyone else. We LOVE to boil things down to absurdities in order to make a point. Without it, we never would have invented lapel buttons and bumper stickers.

    I love a good laugh, from ...either side. Just don't take those little cartoons, bumper stickers and one-liners too seriously. The day they replace constructive argument; the day they do your talking for you, then intelligent human discourse is in big, big trouble.

    Me: Liberals are only funny unintentionally.

    B.R.: Rich - um. what? no.

    K.B.: ‎"When you run out of intelligent argument, switch to name-calling."

    R.W.: The cartoon does not address healthcare. That is irrelevant. It doesn't MATTER what the product or service is. Why is that so difficult? Sometimes things ate really very simple. Can. You be taxed for NOT conforming? The answer is yes. That means that dispite the colonialists in Boston objection to high taxes on tea, how would they have felt if England had impossed a penalty for NOT BUYING tea.

    B.R.: Is that how you feel about all taxes? Are there any taxes that you feel are understandable despite the compromise they represent?

    Me: Joy Behar. Sheila Jackson-Lee. Joe Biden. Al Sharpton. Need I say more?

    K.B.: You lost me. These people are examples of ...?

    R.W.: Of course not, that is a ridiculous statement. Activity can be taxed. But I don't believe that the government should try to control our behavior with taxes. I am not in favor of sin taxes even though I rarely have to pay them. And I certainly don't support a tax on a Non-activity. Why so quick to give up your freedom?

    B.R.: Rich - no, you generally needn't say more. ;-)

    B.R.: I'm quick to make a compromise in support of getting health care to millions of uninsured Americans. I'd be as pissed as you are, if it was actually gum or priuses or things Americans don't actually need.

    Me: And just like a typical liberal, turns personally insulting.

    Me: These people are liberals who are unintentionally funny.

    Me: ‎"Need" is a nebulous concept. Who determines what you "Need?" Government?

    B.R.: C'mon I was kidding...it was just too easy. There are plenty of liberals who are unintentionally funny, just like there are conservatives (see: Mitch McConnell's voice, John Boehner's name and tan, Sarah Palin's brain). But ya can't actually say that liberals aren't funny intentionally. Many of the great political humorists and satirists in American history have been liberal.

    K.B.: Gentlemen, this has been endlessly entertaining, but I need to get back to work.

    We're the only industrialized country that doesn't have universal health care. May I respectfully suggest we take a whack at it and see how it goes?

    K.B.: If it turns into a hideously expensive debacle that causes more problems than it solves (Hello-o-o 18th Amendment!), then I will be leading the charge for its repeal. But give it a chance first.

    Me: Before obamacare, 46 cents of every healthcare dollar was spent by government. As that number has increased over the past 30 years, healthcare has gotten worse. I submit that we have tried it and it has failed.

    Me: ‎"Humor" is a personal taste. Like you insulting me. You thought it was funny, and I didn't. now I know you were jesting, so I retract my statement.
    "Great humorists?" I don't think so. See, I don't think liberals are funny at all when they are making their humor from the liberal perspective. Mostly because their humor about conservatives rely on caricatures and straw men.

    B.R.: You should read more Mark Twain.
    Me: Took a look at a bunch of his quotes. Hardly liberal humor: http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/authors/m/mark_twain.html

    Me: Waiting for an answer. Who determines what you "Need?" Government?

    B.R.: Keep waiting, I don't have an answer. The vast majority of present day Americans will rely on health care during their lifetime to stay healthy and alive.

    B.R.: It's not temporary safety, it's permanent safety, and it's not for me, it's for my fellow Americans who want it very very badly.

    R.W.: Have you seen the polls? Most people do not want it. In fact it had NEVER been above 50%

    B.R.: Yup. It's a bummer but I have my theories on why it's unpopular. I agree with K.B., if five years goes by and it's a total fail and everyone hates it, i'll work to repeal it and put in a single payer system.
    Me: When has a govt program ever been repealed, either due its failure, or because it achieved its objectives?

    Me: The vast majority of Americans rely on all sorts of things. They also make choices and prioritize according to their preferences. On what basis does need become a priority of government? And why are people required to cede to government the decision on what they need?

    The case you are making is dangerous. A government with that much power to do "good" also has enough power to do all sorts of evil. Tell me what remedy the people have to restrain a government that takes care of needs as it determines for you what you need?

    Wednesday, June 27, 2012

    Only my discernment is right - FB Conversation

    C.Y., A FB friend, posted this:

    Things I've Been Pondering On

    I am realizing as I get older how much I have been relying on my parents as watchmen, protectors, and interceders in my life. But in order to mature in Christ I have to take up that responsibility in my life and be my own interceder and protector from the enemy who wants to steal, kill and destroy. Not saying that my parents still intercede on my behalf but I must fight for myself and not rely on someone else doing it for me. The scriptures that I have been pondering upon that speak to this point have been:

    1 Cor. 13:11-12 - When I was a child, I talked like a child, I thought like a child, I reasoned like a child. When I became a man, I put the ways of childhood behind me. For now we see only a reflection as in a mirror; then we shall see face to face. Now I know in part; then I shall know fully, even as I am fully known.

    Ephesians 6:10-17 - Finally, be strong in the Lord and in his mighty power. Put on the full armor of God, so that you can take your stand against the devil’s schemes. For our struggle is not against flesh and blood, but against the rulers, against the authorities, against the powers of this dark world and against the spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly realms. Therefore put on the full armor of God, so that when the day of evil comes, you may be able to stand your ground, and after you have done everything, to stand. Stand firm then, with the belt of truth buckled around your waist, with the breastplate of righteousness in place, and with your feet fitted with the readiness that comes from the gospel of peace. In addition to all this, take up the shield of faith, with which you can extinguish all the flaming arrows of the evil one. Take the helmet of salvation and the sword of the Spirit, which is the word of God.

    J.T.: You go! As you wrestle against the spiritual forces of darkness and have victory in your own life, you will become a beacon in the night for others that you can teach to stand up and fight like you learned!

    Me: You are experiencing one of many such moments in life I would call times of reckoning. A reckoning is an assessment of your status, from the word "reconcile," to make things agree. As you agree more and more with God, you reckon yourself to be dead in the flesh but alive in Christ. You reconcile (bring into agreement) your purposes with God's. You become more christlike.

    My, my, my. How you have grown.

    R.H.: James tells us to jst ask for wisdom, and HE will grant it, and that every obstacle is a great opportunity for thanksgiving, for when our faith is tested, our perseverence is increased and faith is perfected. We can't ask our parents, or friends for this wisdom, but we can certainly ask for prayer for these things, but we must also ask ourselves. :)

    Me: With all due respect to R.H., the body of the believers is a fount of heavenly wisdom. Ironically, you are giving wisdom that a person's source of wisdom is Yahweh?

    R.H.: I am not quite understanding your question exactly? I can read that a few ways, so if you do'nt mind clarifying..... the body is a fountain of wisdom, but lacking in wisdom too. If it were THE fountain of wisdom, then we'd have no need for asking GOD for wisdom, yes? it is good to ask our friends for wisdom, and advice, but ultimately, does not James say to ask? I am pretty sure. I shoudl have phrased it "ask only friends/believers, etc, for this wisdom, but ultimately, it DOES come from GOD, and so, still, we should ask.
    It's a bit like asking John to ask that girl over there for a date, instead of asking her directly. Wouldn't you say?

    Me: Your clarification is acceptable.

    Me: I have found that so many Christians put themselves at the top of the "discernment pyramid" (i.e., they have to check everything told to them). Sometimes as we submit to one another, we find ourselves from time to time in the position of obedience. "Because you said so, I will do it."

    C.Y.: Rich-I'm not quite sure where you are going with "Christians put themselves at the top of the 'discernment pyramid'" would you mind clarifying that for me. I feel like its good stuff but I'm not getting ;)

    Me: A lot of Christians are not truly under authority, in the sense that they seem to always submit the spiritual input they receive from other Christians to their own discernment. This is not to say that we should not be discerning, but our discernment is not perfect, nor is it always the final authority.

    Here's what I mean. Pick out any person you really respect, someone you know to be a mature person of faith. For me that would be someone like Rob Mazza or your dad or Duncan Hill. If one of those men told me I should go do something, I would simply go do it. I would not say, "oh, I need to pray about that."
    I'm not saying that this is always the way it should work. But sometimes it is, because God has appointed people to positions of authority, people whom we should not be reluctant to obey.

    You can see that if everything that is said to you is subject to your discernment, then your discernment is at the top of the pyramid, and you then are really subject to no other human authority but you.

    R.H.: See, Rich, I am not that way. If any of them would tell me to do it, I would question it first. *unless it is something I have been praying about already, pondering, considering, needing a final push in that direction, etc*. Someone tells me to do something, I have to wonder why. Depend ing on the something, of course.

    And yes, when it comes to our own lives, we really have to be discerning, and at the top of our own pyramid that way, because we have our families to look after. We have to wonder what the motivation is behind them. If we have asked for guidance, that is completely different than someone simply telling us what to do. AND even then, we should not take what a human says as final authority, but give it to GOD, and see what the result is. if we rely on everyone else telling us what to do, then we can end up in a big muddle, and no faith either....

    Me: So you are saying that there is no one in your life that you respect enough to obey and submit to? That only you hear God clearly enough, that your discernment is superior to anyone else? Forgive me for my directness, but if I am wrong, I'd like to know what you really meant.

    R.H.: no, there isn't really anyone that Iwould trust to tell me what to do, and me to do without questioning, in ordinary circumstances. I listen to my husband, and regret it every time. but, I do consider what people have to say, and go from ...there. I used to do what anyone who I respected said. but that kept me from growing also. I don't take anyone's word for biblical interpretation as fact either. I ponder it, and study it out my self, and then go from there. everyone has such varied opinions, how can one possibly know what to do if you listen to everyon'e sinput on your lives? THere are a couple of people who I do listen to , and respect, and take to heart what they have to say, but I do not give it final authority. GOD is my final authority in what I do. We can't go about , living our lives, based on what others tell us. what a muddle we'd be in.

    R.H.: now, in emergency situations, great. I may well listen, if I don't have a better solution. when someone says pray, I pray. someone suggests studying something out, I will do so. but for my life choices, no, there's no one who is the final authority above me but God.....

    R.H.: if we become dependent on others to make our choices for us, to fight our battles for us, then we are weak in our faith, and weak in every other area as well. we have no armour, but hid behind those who do have it. What good is that to us?

    C.Y.: Rich I believe I understand. R.H. - the thing about being your own discerner is that we as humans have holes in our thought process that's why we have cults. So yes we shouldn't always rely on other people but we shouldn't always rely just on ourselves. We do need people in our lives to speak truth when we ourselves our blind to it. Its a both and.

    Me: C.Y., I'd like to apologize in advance for hijacking your post.

    R.H., you are changing my definitions. I never recommended that this is always what we should do, or that we should never inquire of God ourselves, or that we should always obey others, or that we should become dependent on others to make our choices for us.

    But I see that you confirmed that there is no one in spiritual authority over you, including your husband. That is troubling.

    R.H.: Rich, let me tell you. My husband doesn't seem to believe in God. He is not interested in religion, grew up with a christian school background, thinks he knows evreything there is to know about the bible, doesn't read it, doesn't pray, is...n't interested in bible study, n o interest in going to church.

    Everytime I have listened to my husband, we have gotten lost, taken longer to get places, things don't get done, etc.

    Now, if you would like to live as I live, then you can judge after the fact.

    R.H.: C.Y., cults: this is exactly why I do not have an "authority" over me telling me what to do. That's why I left BI, because he was trying to tell me what to do in specific areas of my life that are not his to deal with, and it was his way or the high way, and everyone had to believe what HE had to say, regardless of whether we felt it was right or not.

    A spiritual leader is not one who tells you how it is. He tells you how he is led to believe it, and it is up to you to soak it up, and search it out for yourself. I am not in a position where I am leading others except for my family. I am not a cult, and I am not ina position of power. I knwo all about cults, and know the problems of no authority int hat way. That is why there are cults, because there are people controlling the lives of others. Because people take that person to be authority.

    Me: Again, I did not use words like "listen to everyone."

    I also made no commentary on what your husband is like, or what kind of relationship you have with him. Nor did I make any judgments about your life or what kind of person you are.

    Perhaps you might confine your remarks to the topic at hand.

    Me: ‎"Control" and "authority" are not synonymous.

    R.H.: rich, i merely spoke to the fact that you find it troubling that my husband is not an authority over me.

    Me: Actually, once again you are changing what I said. I said I found it troubling that there is no one in spiritual authority over you, including your husband.

    R.H.: You are taking out the "listen to everyone " out of context. there are others whose spirital walk I respect, and should they speak truth to me, you can bet I will take it to heart, and will likely know it is truth. good point, carly. (my pinky finger is bandaged at the moment, so not all things that should be capped may be...) i do not give anyone authority over me, because it has not ever been a good situation. I am merely speaking to the fact that there are people who will tell you, Rich, "jump" and you will obey without question, and I disagree with that. I have been taught an d trained to question motives, and to search things out. should that person be right, I will follow that direction. if I feel that person is wrong, no matter how much I respect that person, I will not go that way. Does that not make sense?

    I take advice of many people. but it is not blindly accepted. THAT is my whole entire point that you seem to be missing.

    R.H.: and you make sure to "include my hsuband". It is not my fault how my husband chooses to walk, but I cannot choose to follow those footsteps. I support my husband, but I hve to pray for his walk to be closer to Adonai, instead of farther away. I find it troubling that a husband must be an "authority". who is the authority over the husband?

    R.H.: and this is a part of this discussion that ends here, becuase it's going to go a wrong direction, nd is of no benefit (I don't think???) to C.Y.. happy to discuss with you privately if you wish, Rich, or on my own wall. No, there is no human authority directl over my life, beyond our government, etc. NO spiritual authority, because I have not found one with whom I can entrust any portion of my life. I still feel that you are judging me because I hve no spiritual authority to whom i would completely submit to, who can tell me to do something, and I do it. I call that discern ment. I am sure I can find in many places in the bible to support my philosophy in this case. There are people in my life whose advice I will take should I ask of it, and NO one who I will blindly follow, just because they say to do something.

    R.H.: I completely agree with C.Y. about being the one responsible for her life and her actions, and not calling up on others to take responsibility for her and her walk, and her faith. That is not to say that she's excluding everyone, but she's carrying her own staff, and taking her own steps, and facing her own obstacles. She may call on others when necessary, and that's very important too.

    Me: Since I did not make a case for obeying without question, it appears we are in agreement.

    "Authority" and "obedience" are not the same. The fact that your husband fails to be the man God has called him to be is unfortunate. Your godly ministry to your husband is explained by 1 Cor 7:14.