-----------------------------
The author has a problem. He's teaching from 1 Corinthians chapter 2, and badly wants this to solely be about understanding the Scriptures. But Paul wasn't talking about the Scriptures. He doesn't even mention the Scriptures until chapter 15.
The author has a problem. He's teaching from 1 Corinthians chapter 2, and badly wants this to solely be about understanding the Scriptures. But Paul wasn't talking about the Scriptures. He doesn't even mention the Scriptures until chapter 15.
This creates a problem for the author, because he doesn't believe in the "supernatural" spiritual gifts, like prophecy (1 Cor. 12:10) or words of knowledge (1 Cor. 12:8). This means the presence of the Holy Spirit in us needs to be limited to conform to the author's preferences.
His faith tradition has created a doctrine to deal with this, illumination vs. revelation. Revelation is supernatural information, only available to the writers of Scripture. Illumination is supernatural information, solely to understand the Scriptures.
The Bible doesn't make this distinction. In fact, the author doesn't quote any Scripture at all, but for some reason he paraphrases several. Why the aversion to actually quoting the verses?
For this reason we must deem this Bad Bible Teaching.
-----------------------
How can we know as believers if we have received the mind of Christ through the indwelling Spirit of God? In 1 Corinthians 2:12, Paul told us that God has revealed the mind of Christ by the Spirit so that we might know the things God has graciously given to us. (Let's quote it:
How can we know as believers if we have received the mind of Christ through the indwelling Spirit of God? In 1 Corinthians 2:12, Paul told us that God has revealed the mind of Christ by the Spirit so that we might know the things God has graciously given to us. (Let's quote it:
1 Cor. 2:12 We have not received the spirit of the world but the Spirit who is from God, that we may understand what God has freely given us.
The author's paraphrase is very nearly a quote. Why doesn't he just go ahead and quote it?)
This verse explains the purpose of the reception of the mind of Christ by believers. God wants us to know the mind of Christ so that we might understand what He has freely bestowed upon us through the cross. (This verse does not mention the cross, nor is it even about the cross. It is specifically about the giving of the Holy Spirit.)
What Paul is describing in this verse is what theologians call the illumination of the Spirit in our minds. (Oh. Theologians. But we'd rather see where this is taught in the Bible, sir. Will that be forthcoming?)
What Paul is describing in this verse is what theologians call the illumination of the Spirit in our minds. (Oh. Theologians. But we'd rather see where this is taught in the Bible, sir. Will that be forthcoming?)
Previously, we encountered the revelation the Spirit gave to the apostles, but now we see the illumination the Spirit gives to all believers. (The author doesn't link to the article, but we think we found it. In it he did nothing but make the assertion. We quote from that article:
That's all he had to say about it. However, there is no such distinction in the Scriptures that revelation is only for the apostles, while regular believers only get illumination. The author simply invents the distinction and doesn't even bother to demonstrate it.
"In verse 10, Paul speaks exclusively of the apostles, because the Spirit does not give divine revelation to every believer."
That's all he had to say about it. However, there is no such distinction in the Scriptures that revelation is only for the apostles, while regular believers only get illumination. The author simply invents the distinction and doesn't even bother to demonstrate it.
Paul uses both words in the space of two verses:
Eph. 1:17-18 I keep asking that the God of our Lord Jesus Christ, the glorious Father, may give you the Spirit of wisdom and revelation, so that you may know him better. 18 I pray also that the eyes of your heart may be enlightened...
"Revelation" is apokalupsis, which means manifestation, be revealed, revelation. "Enlightened" [that is, illumination] is phótizó; to shine, give light... I bring to light, make evident, reveal.
The two words are almost synonymous. The author is making a distinction without a difference.)
To put it simply, the illumination of the Spirit is the ability to understand God’s Word accurately. (The author pulls this out of thin air. Where in the Bible do we find this? There is not a single usage of phótizó that refers to Scripture.)
The Spirit revealed the Word through the apostles and prophets, but that revelation was not enough in itself because apart from the illumination of the Spirit we cannot understand what God’s Word means by what it says. (The author appears to be referencing 1 Cor. 2:14:
The man without the Spirit does not accept the things that come from the Spirit of God, for they are foolishness to him, and he cannot understand them, because they are spiritually discerned.
This is a Category Mistake. "The things that come from the Spirit" is not the same as the Bible.)
The gift of the Spirit is essential to understanding the mind of Christ. (True.)
How then can we understand the meaning of God’s Word? (The author switches back to the Bible. The mind of Christ is not the same as Bible.)
The answer is crucial because anyone can quote or even memorize Scripture, but it doesn’t mean we understand its true meaning. (True.)
How then can we understand the meaning of God’s Word? (The author switches back to the Bible. The mind of Christ is not the same as Bible.)
The answer is crucial because anyone can quote or even memorize Scripture, but it doesn’t mean we understand its true meaning. (True.)
Only the Spirit of God enables us to hear or read divine revelation and rightly understand and interpret it. (True.)
Many years ago, I remember trying to work through the doctrine of justification by faith alone with someone. I would ask him a question about it, and he would quote a verse. This exchange was frustrating because it missed the point of the problem.
The problem was not that one of us did not know what Scripture said, but that we did not agree on its meaning. We could both agree that James 2 or Romans 4 were the inspired word of God, and we might even agree that a particular translation accurately captured the intention of the original Greek text, but that still left a vital question: what does that text actually mean? To get at the meaning of the text requires not merely a human intellect, but divine illumination by the Spirit who inspired that Scripture. (True, but the author presumes he has this illumination while his interlocuter does not. There is no room in his thinking that he might be the one in error.)
Now, we should understand two things about the illumination of the Spirit to help us know what God has graciously given to us in His Word. (Is the verse about His Word? Let's requote:
Many years ago, I remember trying to work through the doctrine of justification by faith alone with someone. I would ask him a question about it, and he would quote a verse. This exchange was frustrating because it missed the point of the problem.
The problem was not that one of us did not know what Scripture said, but that we did not agree on its meaning. We could both agree that James 2 or Romans 4 were the inspired word of God, and we might even agree that a particular translation accurately captured the intention of the original Greek text, but that still left a vital question: what does that text actually mean? To get at the meaning of the text requires not merely a human intellect, but divine illumination by the Spirit who inspired that Scripture. (True, but the author presumes he has this illumination while his interlocuter does not. There is no room in his thinking that he might be the one in error.)
Now, we should understand two things about the illumination of the Spirit to help us know what God has graciously given to us in His Word. (Is the verse about His Word? Let's requote:
1 Cor. 2:12 We have not received the spirit of the world but the Spirit who is from God, that we may understand what God has freely given us.Did God only give us His Word, or is there a vast array of blessings, grace, and favor?)
First, the illumination of the Spirit does not eliminate the need for human effort in understanding Scripture. This point is of vital importance. Someone might say to me, “Pastor, do you believe in the illumination of the Spirit of God in your mind before you preach?” And I would say, “Absolutely, I do. I am totally dependent on the illumination of the Spirit to get anything right in a sermon or any other setting where I am interacting with the Word of God.” And he might reply, “Then why do you need to spend so much time studying and preparing? Why not just get into the pulpit, prayed up and let the Spirit illumine your mind as you go?” And the answer to that is because the illumination of the Spirit does not work independently of human effort. (Sigh. How does he know this? He simply asserts this without anything other than an unedifying story.)
There are two passages that make this point clear. The first is in 2 Timothy 2:7, where Paul asserts his belief in the illumination of the Spirit to open our understanding to the meaning of God’s Word. (The author now lies to us. Let's quote:
2 Tim. 2:5-7 Similarly, if anyone competes as an athlete, he does not receive the victor’s crown unless he competes according to the rules. 6 The hardworking farmer should be the first to receive a share of the crops. 7 Reflect on what I am saying, for the Lord will give you insight into all this.
We quoted a bit more so as to show the context. We discover that the Bible is not under discussion. Paul was telling Timothy that he would come to understand Paul's statements as God grants him insight.)
Paul, here, tells Timothy that the Lord will give him understanding in everything already revealed. Understanding comes from the Lord, not from men.
Paul, though, begins the verse with a command: consider what I say! This shows us that illumination is not automatic. (Sigh... The author is making things up. Paul was not making a statement about the author's doctrine of illumination, he simply told Timothy to stop and think about it. There is no mystery meaning in this statement.)
We don’t just open our Bibles and receive immediate understanding from the Holy Spirit. (Undocumented statement.)
Rather, God designed illumination such that we employ our minds to think on His Word to understand it. (Undocumented statement.)
If and when we consider and prayerfully meditate on God’s Word, the Spirit will enable believers to understand it. (Undocumented statement.)
The second passage is in 2 Timothy 2:15, where Paul tells Timothy that he must be diligent, and that Timothy is to think of himself as a workman as he handles the word of truth. (Sigh again... Let's quote it:
2 Tim. 2:15 Do your best to present yourself to God as one approved, a workman who does not need to be ashamed and who correctly handles the word of truth.
"Word" is logos in Greek. This is not the Bible, it is the Word spoken, the epitome of which is the Word Himself (John 1:1). If Paul was talking about the Bible he would have used the Greek word graphé, like he does in the next chapter, 2 Timothy 3:16.
So Paul was counseling Timothy to correctly handle the things he has heard, which particularly would be what Paul has been teaching him.
The author gets this totally wrong. We no longer think he is a competent Bible teacher.)
Studying and understanding Scripture takes diligence. There is no room for laziness in the lives of those who would rightly understand and communicate divine truth.
This diligence is what will enable Timothy to accurately handle the word of truth. Timothy needed to be diligent and work hard. Paul believed in the illumination of the Spirit, but he also knew the Spirit uses means to illumine our minds – and one of the means He uses is our diligent study and meditation on the Word of God.
So, we see that illumination is necessary to understanding God’s Word, but it does not eliminate the need for diligent study and meditation of Scripture. (The author has hammered this point over and over. This is what he really wanted to discuss. The illumination of the Holy Spirit, having been "contextualized," can be pared down to the intellectual process of merely studying the Bible.)
Second, the goal of illumination is not merely a clearer understanding of the text of Scripture, but of the realities those texts describe.
Paul says in 1 Corinthians 2:12 that God gave us His Spirit so we might know the things freely given to us by Him. (Sighhhhhh... Let's quote yet again:
This diligence is what will enable Timothy to accurately handle the word of truth. Timothy needed to be diligent and work hard. Paul believed in the illumination of the Spirit, but he also knew the Spirit uses means to illumine our minds – and one of the means He uses is our diligent study and meditation on the Word of God.
So, we see that illumination is necessary to understanding God’s Word, but it does not eliminate the need for diligent study and meditation of Scripture. (The author has hammered this point over and over. This is what he really wanted to discuss. The illumination of the Holy Spirit, having been "contextualized," can be pared down to the intellectual process of merely studying the Bible.)
Second, the goal of illumination is not merely a clearer understanding of the text of Scripture, but of the realities those texts describe.
Paul says in 1 Corinthians 2:12 that God gave us His Spirit so we might know the things freely given to us by Him. (Sighhhhhh... Let's quote yet again:
1 Cor. 2:12 We have not received the spirit of the world but the Spirit who is from God, that we may understand what God has freely given us.
We simply can't understand why the author refuses to quote the Bible.)
One of those things is the Word of God, ("One of those things?" Ah, finally. So there's more to this than simply the illumination of the Scriptures? Sir, what might that be? Oh. He won't explain.)
but God’s Word contains divine promises that are only experienced and realized as we live out our faith and walk with the Lord. (This appears to be bad paraphrase of 2 Peter 1:3:
His divine power has given us everything we need for a godly life through our knowledge of him who called us by his own glory and goodness.Very bad paraphrase, since the verse is about His divine power, not the Bible.)
For example, the Bible promises us peace through the cross of Christ, peace with God and others, and peace in our own hearts and minds. One goal of illumination is that we might understand God has graciously given us peace through Christ. We must have an intellectual grasp of the meaning and application of this peace.
Another goal, though, goes beyond an intellectual understanding of this peace to an experience of this peace. God has revealed He has given us this peace in His Word, and He wants us to know this peace in our lives.
So, the Spirit illumines us to the meaning of Scripture, not only so our minds will grasp the meaning, but so that meaning will permeate our lives and transform us from the inside-out. God has given the Spirit to Christians so we might know, understand, and experience the things He has freely given us in the gospel.
That is, then, the purpose of the reception of Christ’s mind, so we might know God has freely given to us in Christ things that are revealed by the Spirit in the Word and that radically transform us as we understand the Word.
About Robb Brunansky
Robb pastors Desert Hills Bible Church in Glendale, Arizona. He has his M. Div. from The Master’s Seminary and his Ph.D. in New Testament from The Southern Baptist Theological Seminary.
No comments:
Post a Comment